Most of the time, what makes me respect a player is not only his athletic ability but the class they show on and off the field.
New York Jets:
Curtis Martin - One of the classiest guys in the NFL, quietly had several consecutive 1000+ rushing seasons, never complains, is a model on and off the field. He's probably my favorite non-Dolphin player in the AFC East
Jonathan Vilma - Had a fabulous rookie season, and of course, played for UM.
Buffalo Bills:
Willis McGahee - Recovering from his ACL injury was amazing, let alone how he tore up the NFL last year.
Eric Moulds - Just respect this guy as a player, enjoy watching him.
Takeo Spikes - Same as above.
New England Patriots:
Tom Brady - Unlike some other Patriots, he never complains about the "lack of respect" he and the Patriots recieve. Doesn't whine about money, just a guy who geniunely enjoys playing the game. Again, a model on and off the field.
Deion Branch - same as Moulds.