I picked other, because I am hoping Dan comes out of retirement to play again. In all seriousness, I would have picked Brady. He doesn't have the glamour numbers for a qb, but the boy knows how to win. Manning has the numbers but seems to always fall apart in a big game, vick I'm not sold on yet and forget the others.
Even though Peyton Manning is by far the best QB, I went with Drew Brees. He's younger, more mobile and athletic, and he's not the entire team. If Manning went down in Indy, their season's over. I prefer a more low-key guy who can win games.
Michael Vick honestly wouldn't be my first option because I feel we have too good of WR's for Vick to be our QB. I think Peyton Manning and Tom Brady are better at running a team and utilizing each and every single player. But personally I really like mobile QB's who can throw which is why I would really like Daunte Culpepper and Donovan McNabb because behind out O-line they might fair well the best. There's no telling how Manning would perform behind our O-line because he is not a mobile QB the slightest bit, and I don't want to say he would struggle I just don't think he would put up his typical Peyton Manning numbers or be best suited as some of the QB's on that list. Quite honestly, I would take almost any QB on that list. I don't want to be pessimistic, but you really can't deny that almost everyone on that list is better than what we have by far. But yeah I'm taking the easy way out... Peyton Manning throwing to Chris Chambers, Marty Booker, David Boston, and Randy McMichael, you'd be :crazy:CRAZY to pass up on that.
I would take Manning. I think he's the best QB in the league right now. His fakes on play action are incredible and he does a great job with audibles. But you could pick 4 or 5 guys off that list and not go wrong.