Wny not Troy Smith!

[Crowder52]

I think I've seen a few more QB's than you in my time Geforce..:D

I find it hard to believe you don't think he has an awesome arm.
Thats one thing for sure he has...

Perhaps you haven't seen Jamarcus Russell.

 

[phinfan_1]

I doubt you have seen a few more QBs than I have since I'v been following football since 1969.

Smith has a good arm but it's not the best since Jeff George. There's a quarterback in this draft that has a better arm and his name is JaMarcus Russell.

Man Geforce your an old man...:D..you must be around my age.

Yeah JR has an awesome arm also...strong arm.

But George and Troy smith have that shorter throwing motion and yet the ball catapults off there hands. Looks better to..

 

[Alex44]

Not many people had Smith as a first rounder to begin with.

Anyway his arm is strong but not amazing, and he can be accurate but isnt even that accurate. He has speed, but isnt really THAT fast.

Id say he will be a good backup QB, maybe a starter in 3-4 years.

 

[Dors156]

i'd go crazy if he would drop to us in the SECOND round. but IMO hes not a first rounder

 

[jlfin]

3rd or 4th..:rofl: Never!!

Yeah, those 30 something yds he threw for in the Fiesta Bowl were quite an accomplishment.
When all is said and done, he will be lucky to be drafted before the 5th rd.

 

[clbrazee]

Too short for the NFL. He would have to convert to a CB or S.