Not calling you out, just stating it's easy to be critical when you're not backing up your point of view. I appreciate you taking the time to present your grades with the accompanying commentary. That was much better than telling him his grades were trash without giving the reasons why you disagree.His analysis is terrible.
My grades on O would be since you calling me out:
QB - C met expectations, made things happen with his legs, escaped pressure at times, and gave Dolphins a chance, good enough for a back up
WR - D, below expectations, did not make anything happen, caught a few underneath throws basically all game.
TE - C this position was underutilized in the passing game, but Mike made a couple of big catches late. They blocked okay.
RB - D did not make it happen today, failed to find creases, not good enough in short yardage, Gaskin was called upon on screens and failed to execute, There was a rushing TD which bumps the grade to D, otherwise would be an F.
OL - C they did their job today. They got beat a few times, but overall they held up, created holes, blocked downfield and gave Jacoby time and lanes to do something.
OC - F basically lost the game.
But let me drive this point to you: His grades are jaded and garbage!
His grades are his opinions, the same as yours. It may be quite possible you both viewed the game a bit differently and are using different benchmarks, which isn't unusual. After seeing your grades I must admit, you're pretty damn good with handing out grades, quite possibly the best I've seen around here. You obviously have a keen eye and a much broader knowledge of the game to be able to be so accurate in your grading, my apologies are in order.
But let me drive this point to you: You should try to show a bit more respect and be less confrontational around here.
By the way, your grades are garbage...