I keep seeing statements like this one and my only question would be: Do the 2007 AFC Championship and Super Bowl victories not count all of a sudden? You can call it a fluke or say it was only one Super Bowl, but it's one more than your team or mine has over the last thirty years. Peyton will be fine if his defense gives him some support in the playoffs...
He has his one title, he has had SB caliber talent around him for about a decade and has just ONE appearance in a playoff year he had one great half('06 title game) and was mediocre the rest of the playoffs.
The D has been good enough to win w/. They have lost games giving up 19, 17 in regulation(twice), 20, 21, 22, ...
They haven't been losing games 38-34, the one game they gave up 41 pts the offense scored ZERO. It's possible to win a game allowing 41 pts, it's impossible to win a game scoring ZERO.
Typical Jest fan.
Why don't you actually look up P. Manning's stats, average them out then take oh...I don't know...T. Brady's stats and compare them. You may be surprised at what you find.
I'll help you out:
Brady post season QBR 88
Manning post season QBR 86.9
Brady has more post season wins because his defense, running game and coaches have been better. Retards like to spout off how Manning has "choked" in big games when in fact the Colts defense has choked.
For example, the Colts have scored 24 or less points ten times in the post season since Manning's been there. They have lost 8 out of those 10 games.
The Pats have scored 24 or less points ten times in the post season since Brady has been there. They have lost 2 out of those 10 games.
So let me explain that to you, a brain dead Jest fan:
Manning has played just as well as Brady in the playoffs even though he has been under more pressure to score, had crappier run game support and had inferior coaches.
Manning is going to retire as one of the top 10 (maybe top 5 ) greatest QB's to ever play in the NFL. Brady will retire and be remembered as another Aikmen, Bradshaw or Griese. HOF'er, yes, but no where near the greatest.
No I'm not a typical fan at all, typical fans THINK Peyton is better than Brady b/c he puts up better fantasy #s in the regular season but those of us that watch and understand the games see what he does in january and how he has struggled while Brady has been great.
The QB ratings in postseason are close so they must be close! You show how little you know.
Did you know in regulation the Colts D has allowed less than 2 PPG less than the "great" NE defense in postseason?
Did you know in 8 playoff losses Peyton has led that high powered O to less than 14 PPG on average?
Did you know Peyton has gone one and done SIX times? Brady never.
Did you know Peyton is 0-3 when he has a bye? Brady undefeated.
Did you know Bill Belichick never got as far as a conf title game w/o Brady and that Tony Dungy once made a conf title game w/ Shaun King as his QB?
Did you know that in their SB run Peyton threw 3 TDs and 7 INTs in their 4 postseason games?
Did you know that in 3 SB title runs Brady threw a total of 3 INTs.
Did you know Brady led last minute SB victories in 2 of his 3 title years?
Did you know in the lone SB loss he led his team 80 yds in the final minutes? has Peyton ever had a postseason loss where he led his on a late scoring drive only to watch his D give it up?
Did you know that the first year Brady got weapons comparable to what Manning had his entire career he smashed records and led them to a 16-0 season and another SB?
keep reading stat sheets, like the one that tells you he had a good game w/ a 90 rating against Pitt in '05 even though he was terrible and cost them that game.