I'd rather have Fitz than Marshall, only because Fitz has no red flags. Speaking of their games on the field, I flip a coin. I've posted before that Marshall is something of a mix between A. Johnson and L. Fitzgerald. I also think that many people downplay Marshall's ability to stretch the field. He's not as fast as A. Johnson, but to my eyes, he's faster than Fitzgerald. He doesn't have the ball skills that Fitzgerald does, but he's probably better in that category than any other WR in the NFL. He's also in the top two WR's in regard to RAC (the other being A. Johnson - Boldin's 3rd, in my eyes). So, when you combine his ball skills and his RAC, he's an amazing weapon.
C. Johnson is the most talented WR in the NFL. It's hard to say what he might do within the context of a real offense, but I don't think you can award him a spot over top-tier WR's because of his potential.
C. Johnson is the most talented WR in the NFL. It's hard to say what he might do within the context of a real offense, but I don't think you can award him a spot over top-tier WR's because of his potential.