I do agree with Alex22 when he said a Heisman doesn't make a great QB. There have been PLENTY of Heisman winner that do little or nothing in the NFL. Plus, I have always thought the Heisman to be a bit of a joke and not very accurate and true for one simple fact. All the past winners have a vote. What's to stop them from just continuing to vote for whomever is from their Alma-Mater so their school continues to produce "heimsan winning" players? I'm not saying this is a regular occurance or some conspiracy or something, but you have to know that happens. For example, Matt Leinart said he gave Reggie his pick this year because Reggie asked for it. Now, I think Reggie definately deserved it this year, but lets say (hypothetically speaking) that Vince Young had the better season, do you think Leinart would have voted against his teammate and good friend? No, I think Bush was getting his vote either way. That's just a confirmed example because Leinart flat out TOLD the media Reggie asked for the vote and Matt gave it to him, but you KNOW those older players, and even some younger ones, are voting for players from their Alma-Maters instead of who they truely think is the best.
Also, I'm no "draft guru" but I have seen Leinart play quite often, as I spend half the year in Souther California and half in Hawai'i, USC's games are ALWAYS on in both places. I'm not sold on Leinart. I know he has talent, but I don't see him transferring to a great NFL QB. He may be able to cut it in the league, but I never see him becoming great. I have seen him struggle in the easiest of situations and throw plenty of balls that never should have been thrown. I too question his arm strength, and I also question where his career would be if he DIDN'T have a Reggie Bush, LenDale White, Steve Smith, Dwayne Jarrett, etc etc.