Originally posted by Muck
Nick Buoniconti was pretty much the same size as Zach Thomas is today. Hell, he was as big as guys like Ian Gold, Barrett Green. Larry Csonka was listed at 237 lbs but most say he was closer to 260 on gameday. Surely that size would translate today. Paul Warfield's size would still be big enough.
One thing you must consider is the fact that many players back then could have trained today and gotten bigger than they were.
Alot of today's teams could beat up on the old greats. But to be fair, today's teams wouldn't translate to be as big as they are today. Guys are blown up to play football. Look at Brad Culpepper. He played between 285-295 lbs his entire career with the Bucs and Bears. One year later, he's a 190 lb lawyer at Morgan, Colling, and Gilbert. So it's not as if those guys were as big as they could have possibly gotten.
And there's always the mental side of the game. Those Dolphins just didn't make mental mistakes, period. Execution, execution, execution.
Finally, I'd put Shula/Arnsparger up against anyone.