A.J. Feeley | Page 3 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

A.J. Feeley

finnyboy002 said:
Nevemind our situation, your O-Line will be terrible this year and so will Lossman :roflmao:
Click to expand...
you too kid. :mad:
 
NJFINSFAN1 said:
The only reason he stepped onto the field in Philly was because the two QB's in front of him got hurt!

You can color it anyway you want, up until now, he was not worth a 2nd pick!
Click to expand...

see so up until now hes not worth a 2nd pick?

so was david carr woth a number 1 pick overall? was carson palmer? was eli manning? cause with your philosophy with inexperienced QBs they need to perform right away or they are not worth even a 2nd round pick... never mind a number 1 overall...
 
#1

You Can Never Convince A Feeley Hater He Is Better Than He Showed Last Year Because Our Whole Offense Was Lousy Last Year,

#2
He Could Very Well Be A Good Qb As Saban Hasn't Made Qb A Priority Except For Aquiring A Saftey Net,

#3
If You Need To Try To Convince Someone That Feeley Is A Decent Option Vs. A Second Rounder ....save It And Let It Play Out Itself.....IT'S TOO SOON TO Evaluate Him from last year.......even Though Saban Already Did By Not Going Qb In Round 1,2,3,4,5,6,7
 
pcfin said:
I would bet that Feeley's passer rating will be better than Losman's. Growing pains will kill Losman. Unless your name is Marino or Roethlisberger, rookies don't fare well. And yes, Losman is a rookie.
Click to expand...
:mad:
 
If you ask any NFL draft/personnel guy out there to rank the QB staffs of the 32 NFL teams, consensus would be that Miami is DEAD LAST or close to it. 25 teams WITHOUT QUESTION are better off at that position than we are, and the other all have a developmental guy that will soon be starter caliber. We have 2 3rd-stringers and a camp arm, and just signed a guy that the home town fan base despises.

WE HAVE TO MAKE A QB MOVE! Why can't people understand this?

FEELEY is NEVER going to be an upper-tier NFL QB. He is below-mediocre level. FREROTTE is a standing joke among other NFL teams/fanbases. No one wants the guy. It's ridiculous.
 
Mark Brunell was traded for a third-round and a fifth-round pick to Jacksonville after throwing the ball TWENTY-SEVEN times over two seasons. The guy had basically no experience and still garnered that kind of value. He was traded again - as a backup now - for a third round pick. If a 34 year old backup was traded from one backup spot (behind Leftwich) to a possible starting spot (he ended a backup anyway) for a third rounder, then Feeley was worth it.

It's like you people have no idea what QB's are worth as far as trade value. Seriously, starting QB's are NEVER traded.
 
GRT8 said:
#1

You Can Never Convince A Feeley Hater He Is Better Than He Showed Last Year Because Our Whole Offense Was Lousy Last Year,

#2
He Could Very Well Be A Good Qb As Saban Hasn't Made Qb A Priority Except For Aquiring A Saftey Net,

#3
If You Need To Try To Convince Someone That Feeley Is A Decent Option Vs. A Second Rounder ....save It And Let It Play Out Itself.....IT'S TOO SOON TO Evaluate Him from last year.......even Though Saban Already Did By Not Going Qb In Round 1,2,3,4,5,6,7
Click to expand...

true... its funny cause im not convinced hes a great QB i dont know how anyone could be convinced either way... but its just the unfair reputation he gets on this board is CRAZY... i dont know why people wanna hate him so bad, i guess they need a scapegoat for last season or something...
 
flintsilver7 said:
Seriously, starting QB's are NEVER traded.
Click to expand...

This is why you HAVE to draft QB every chance you get, even to exclusion of other positions. It IS THAT important.
 
flintsilver7 said:
Mark Brunell was traded for a third-round and a fifth-round pick to Jacksonville after throwing the ball TWENTY-SEVEN times over two seasons. The guy had basically no experience and still garnered that kind of value. He was traded again - as a backup now - for a third round pick. If a 34 year old backup was traded from one backup spot (behind Leftwich) to a possible starting spot (he ended a backup anyway) for a third rounder, then Feeley was worth it.

It's like you people have no idea what QB's are worth as far as trade value. Seriously, starting QB's are NEVER traded.
Click to expand...
Brunnel was once upon a time a probowler. Feely is still considered below average after 5 (?) years in the nfl.
 
arsenal said:
see so up until now hes not worth a 2nd pick?

so was david carr woth a number 1 pick overall? was carson palmer? was eli manning? cause with your philosophy with inexperienced QBs they need to perform right away or they are not worth even a 2nd round pick... never mind a number 1 overall...
Click to expand...

Yes, they have much, much more upside then Feeley. Palmer had a decent season, and never looked as Bad as AJ. As much as Carr has struggled, he has never looked as bad as AJ. And Manning, are you kidding me, Aj will never be as good as Eli, and Eli never looked as bad as AJ.

I'll say it again, AJ was not worth a 2nd round pick, and we could have gotten him for less!!

PS

Honestly tell me you would rather have AJ then one of the above QB's???
 
clajoie_7 said:
I would much rather have Lossman though. He will be a good qb...
Click to expand...
Even though you speak the truth it's still :topic:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom