BRown Or MCgahee??? | Page 11 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

BRown Or MCgahee???

Justasportsfan said:
No , but the premise of the thread is that an unproven Rb w/ so much potential is better than a proven rb. while Losman who just like Brown has so much potential is worse than an unproven qb who recently showed that he sucks? Feely has been in the league for 5 years now and if you grade his performance so far, he's been nothing but a below average qb.



Must be teal/orange glass wearing finfan logic. :crazy:
Click to expand...

He goes from backing up Donovan to having to learn a brand new system. 5 years where he wasn't taking the pounding, but learning how the game is played. Time will tell, just like Ronnie and Willis.:rolleyes:
 
Cobra said:
MaGahee is a STUD!
He will surpass any RB that was drafted in 2005.
Both in this upcoming year and overall career assuming all remain relatively healthy.
Click to expand...
:lolcry:

:shakeno:

Marino1983
 
Cobra said:
MaGahee is a STUD!
He will surpass any RB that was drafted in 2005.
Both in this upcoming year and overall career assuming all remain relatively healthy.
Click to expand...

I think you Bills fans forget about him Blowing his knee out..He looked like a flamingo-- his knee went backwards..It was a miracle he even played again and it's going to be another miracle for him to last very long..He is one hit away from being done for good!! Brown is unproven just like losman, we will find out this year..:cooldude:
 
losman7,
as a fin fan living in buffalo....i have to give you credit. your posts are good. you seem to be able to seperate out emotion with logic. i for one think your posts are pretty much on the money. As for who is better between willis and ronnie...all i can say is i hope they both succeed because it will really liven up the rivalry agian just like it was with marino and kelly. it will just make the wins that much sweeter and the losses that much more bitter to swallow. but isnt that the fun of sports and being a fan?!!
 
Mc Gahee is one of the best backs in the league and his only in his first year..He is not "Overrated".. Willis is the ****. Remember the Stiff Arm on Edwards??
 
Its obvious that the person is bias when they say that a RB who got drafted in an average RB class, was draft in the 26th overall (if i recall) otherwise in the late 1st round, would be selected ahead of the first RB at #2 overall taken in the deepest most talented RB draft pool in decades.
 
dominizzo said:
who will be the better rb in the long run Willis ''Overrated" McGahee or Ronnie "What Can Brown Do For You Today"

My pick Ronnie Brownhes just a do it all player, whereas Willis is just a slash runner and thas it
Click to expand...


take your teal glasses off please


ronnie MIGHT be better but there's no doubting McGahee is a great back
 
phinsforever said:
Are you for real??? You admonish us finfans for 'believ[ing] every report you read from every no-nothing(sic), wanna-be expert" and yet you include a bunch of quotes from people INSIDE the Bills organisation. Dude, get your head out of Ralph Wilson's a$$. What do you expect the Bills' coaches and players to say? That the kid is a problem child with an extremely bad attitude? I remember the way Bills fans reacted when Bledsoe came aboard. The great majority of fans were whooping it up, claiming they had just nabbed the next great QB. The arrival of Losman is no different. And his success, or lack thereof, will be no different from Bledsoe or Rob Johnson. He's just a hot shot college kid who will be out of the league in 5 years. Book it.
Click to expand...


he will be a back-up in 2
 
dominizzo said:
who will be the better rb in the long run Willis ''Overrated" McGahee or Ronnie "What Can Brown Do For You Today"

My pick Ronnie Brownhes just a do it all player, whereas Willis is just a slash runner and thas it
Click to expand...


Without even reading one post I can honestly say this comprison is ridiculous. It's stuff like this that makes us look like unrealistic fans. How can we compare a back who hasn't taken a carry in the NFL to one who has succeeded pretty well in limited action. Right now McGahee is better, hands down, from what I've seen of NFL action. Just like right now I'd have to say Ricky, when healthy and mentally stable, is better than McGahee becuase he's has more NFL success. Willis looks like the real deal and shouldn't be compared with Ronnie at this point but with his very limited success he can't be compared to Ricky, or Dillon or even Martin yet. After next season this whole situation will change but now this is how it is.
 
CRAZYDOLFAN305 said:
Mc Gahee is one of the best backs in the league and his only in his first year..He is not "Overrated".. Willis is the ****. Remember the Stiff Arm on Edwards??
Click to expand...

And he stiff-armed the crap outta Ray Lewis too...
 
whats with the bills fans all of a sudden being reasonable? anyways this is pages past, but brady has made mistakes before in the big game, do u guys remember the int he threw to reggie howard on the goaline in the superbowl vs carolina, couldve cost them the game...thats not saying much though since u can basically count the guys mistakes on one hand throughout his whole career...
 
McGahee isnt overrated, he is a damn good player. His knee worries me even though it didnt seem to bother him last year. Right now I have no idea who I'd take, get back to me in a few years and we'll see where both guys are at.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom