Man-oh-man, you guys are really closed minded about even considering it.
I'm disappointed, but will agree to not bring it up any more.
I lost.
We aren't close minded...we can just see the train wreck coming a mile away. I think I speak for most of us when I say we are Miami Dolphins fans before we are fans of a particular player. The problem with Tebow isn't Tebow, it's his fans. They're like groupies. They follow him place to place, trash the joint and then bolt when he leaves. Bunch of bandwagoners...
I really feel bad for the guy. His fans are the reason he probably won't get another legitimate chance to be a QB in the NFL. When I say his fans, I don't mean the rational ones. I mean the crazy ones that think he could be a starting QB just because he's a great guy and a "Winner", regardless of skill.
Say the Phins sign him against everyone's better judgement, there is no possible outcome that ends well for the Dolphins other then Timmy leading them to a Superbowl. (Not gonna happen) Everybody says "give him a chance!" I agree, but not on this team. If Henne was still the QB sucking it up, I'd say what the hell, give him a shot.
Right now we have a pretty good, potentially great, young QB in Tannehill. We have the league's best backup in Moore and we have the "teacher's pet" in Devlin. Right now, Tebow MIGHT be better than Devlin. I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt. So we make him our third stringer, then all his fans cry, "Give him a chance!" and create a QB controversy. If his fans don't do it the media will. It will eat the team from the inside out. He is a cancer, all because of the media and his fans.
Also, I REALLY wish people would stop this "He was a winner in college" crap. A lot of QB's were good/great college players that sucked in the pros and I sure don't hear people shouting from the rooftops to give Vince Young, Matt Leinart, JaMarcus Russell, Brady Quinn, etc... another chance. The reason some of them are still in the league is because they don't have a psychotic circus following their every move.
BTW, the Broncos defense was pretty darn good the year that he made miracles. We should also ignore the fact that the same Broncos team that he "made" barely a winner, is now one of the best teams in the league under Manning.
ARRGGGG!!! I HATE THE OFFSEASON! Bring on week 1 so we can end this crap!