McDaniel on Open Mike: "We're sitting on a gold mine." | Page 5 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

McDaniel on Open Mike: "We're sitting on a gold mine."

This is fascinating not only for the Tua specific stuff, but for McDaniel’s team building philosophy. Prioritizing skill guys on offense over offensive line, even over the objections of the front office, is a pretty rare approach. Definitely not traditional. But it obviously worked.

We’ve seen much of the same this off-season. We’ve spent money on the secondary, on a linebacker, on another WR/KR/PR—but not really on the offensive line.

I fully recognize and acknowledge that I’m not qualified to be an NFL GM or HC or Scout.

Having said that, I was making the argument for prioritizing “elite playmakers” over “lineman” prior to the 2021 draft.

In this day and age of rules and how the game is played, it just made sense to me.

While I recognize the importance of BOTH the offensive and defensive lines, I feel it’s easier to find and develop lineman with lower picks (the Cheatriot way) than it is to get the Tyreek Hill’s and Jaylen Waddle’s of the world (Tyreek was only a 3rd round pick due to the trouble he got into).

Not only that, getting the ball out quickly to elusive speed guys like Hill and Waddle with a super accurate QB like Tua makes the line better w/o upgrading a single player.

However, they managed to add Armstead and Williams last season, which, when healthy, also went a long way toward improvement.

Now a big challenge is adding more talent and depth to the line.
 
I've now gone through almost all of the posts and some of the great recaps of what McD has said on this issue. I have come to the following realization.


Mike McDaniel is a genius...mascarading as a comedian, who also has one of only 32 positions available in the entire world. I would logically say, therefore, that McD is Great. And anyone who thinks otherwise is a(n)_______________________________________________. Go ahead and name yourself what you may actually be. (friendly, wise, empathetic emoticon here please)
 
Last edited:
Thing with the OL is it isnt a top heavy group. Your worst player on the starting group has more impact on play to play outcome than your best one... I understood the Armstead signing, I'd I'd rather have 2 solids than 1 great when trying to fix that problem.
That is how I am. Give me 5 solid OL over 2 elite and 3 crap or whatever. I hope maybe they would sign that guy LAC cut. Who know maybe they have talked a bit and will make an official offer Jun 1 with the Jones money.
 
I've now gone through almost all of the posts and some of the great recaps of what McD has said on this issue. I have come to the following realization.


Mike McDaniel is a genius mascarading as a comedian who also has one of only 32 positions available in the entire world. I would say therefore, that McD is Great. And anyone who thinks otherwise is ________________________________________________. Go ahead and name yourself what you may actually be. (friendly, wise, empathetic emoticon here please)
Envious af. I am anyways. Imagine the tail coach gets...oops sorry forgot he is married with children. So was Al Bundy I guess.
 
I've now gone through almost all of the posts and some of the great recaps of what McD has said on this issue. I have come to the following realization.


Mike McDaniel is a genius...mascarading as a comedian, who also has one of only 32 positions available in the entire world. I would logically say, therefore, that McD is Great. And anyone who thinks otherwise is a(n)_______________________________________________. Go ahead and name yourself what you may actually be. (friendly, wise, empathetic emoticon here please)

Anyone who thinks otherwise is a lemming.
 
I don’t believe MM believes that MIA doesn’t need to improve the line. They do. And he knows it.

I think it was more about the belief that getting YAC play makers was more of a priority cause it could help speed things along quicker. Getting the ball out quickly to players that can do something with it not only helps the QB but makes it so the line doesn’t have to hold up as long. And unlike before, the receivers getting the ball can make one move and be gone.

I made a similar argument prior to the 2021 Draft, lobbying for one of the stud receivers (Smith, Chase, Waddle, Pitts) over the available lineman. I still believe MIA made the correct choice.

Lastly, I’ve been saying for quite a long time that Grier drafts and prioritizes FA/trades per the needs and wants of his HC and staff. That’s been his M.O.

For good or bad, he trusts his HC and believes in the Parcells ideology of shopping for the type of groceries the staff wants most.
I believe when you go to the bathroom you can't see ur junk? Wait. What!?? Actually, I now believe that you are most wise while having a tendency to state your position in complicated sentences that lend to being inititally misunderstood... but.. that are quite complete and all encompassing, when the reader takes the time, to fully understand said position.


I also believe that I'm goin to Tony Roma's tonight for Bountiful Beef Ribs takeout, to celebrate the realization, that we have finally found our "Head Coach"

RIP Don Shula.
 
I fully recognize and acknowledge that I’m not qualified to be an NFL GM or HC or Scout.

Having said that, I was making the argument for prioritizing “elite playmakers” over “lineman” prior to the 2021 draft.

In this day and age of rules and how the game is played, it just made sense to me.

While I recognize the importance of BOTH the offensive and defensive lines, I feel it’s easier to find and develop lineman with lower picks (the Cheatriot way) than it is to get the Tyreek Hill’s and Jaylen Waddle’s of the world (Tyreek was only a 3rd round pick due to the trouble he got into).

Not only that, getting the ball out quickly to elusive speed guys like Hill and Waddle with a super accurate QB like Tua makes the line better w/o upgrading a single player.

However, they managed to add Armstead and Williams last season, which, when healthy, also went a long way toward improvement.

Now a big challenge is adding more talent and depth to the line.
GM's are people just like you.......they just have more information on players......you could do just as good or better than any other GM's.......people think GM are perfect just because they work for an NFL team but again, they're just regular people that make mistakes just like us.
 


On his interview with the Fins:
"This is everything I ever wanted. I've been in 6 different organizations. This place has all the utilities, and just needs the right Head Coach."

How did you evaluate Tua?
"There was a specific moment....when I first started assessing the situation, you have the 5th pick in the draft, all his experiences thus far in the NFL, it was hard to look at him and not think of my own experience.....I knew I would have had no chance had I not been built up by my mom, that I can do anything. You are the smartest, etc. I knew at a young age that I gravitated to that. It gave me the confidence. We all have those moments of uncertainty, I don't know what is going to happen, and so do you go into those moments with faith you are going to get it done or apprehension you are going to fail? And I had gone through all those moments with vigor and fearlessness because of how I was built up. And so I saw Tua like that. How can we approach the idea of we know what this player is, when I don't know, from my vantage point, who does this guy have that believes in him? So we have to start with, he has to know, someone is 100% in his corner. Which is what a coach is. And no dude, you can do it. I had to convince him that I believed in him so that he in turn could.

There was a particular moment that set everything off. Early March. Going through free agency. We are meeting with all the scouts and coaches in a room. We need to do this that etc. All the directions we could go as a team. I knew in my mind, Tua needed skill positions players that were dynamic with the ball in their hands. Because I knew this dude was a Point Guard. He is gifted that way. And then some of the people in personnel said we need to spend money on Offensive Linemen. I knew that I disagreed with it. But I hate going "NO, because I said so!" So I took the information and went back to the office. I put on the tape and began cutting tape to show the staff what I'm talking about from my lens. As I progress through the tape, I start to notice this trend, wow this is like the 7th different outbreak that I have seen Tua throw to the field....I see this once or twice from a QB in an entire season normally. The WR is running away from you, the ball is in the air longer, high risk throw. He would make pin point throws doing this.

What started as a explanation of how guys needed to be more open for Tua, turned into a marvel session that started at 630pm and went until midnight on a random week day in the offseason. I ended compiling this thing...I thought I knew, but I didn't know...what we were actually sitting on. I'm freaking out. I know for a fact from this night of study that this is the best QB for our offense that I have ever had the chance to coach. And I'm freaking out. So then I call Anne Nolan. Head of PR. Write this date down. I call Chris Grier at midnight. I just got to tell you, I've gone through 700 different passes, and I cannot believe what I am seeing. This guy is doing stuff that I have not focused all my attention on quite yet. We are sitting on a gold mine. We need to do EVERYTHING moving forward to acquire skill position players that have the ability to do stuff with the ball in their hands, because this guy, if they are open, he will get it to them.

In SF I saw the vision, the YAC. But it's 2am. I can't sleep. I need to show the whole organization the tape TODAY. We need a staff meeting at 8am. Get all the scouts in. I need to show this tape. I have to get this off my chest. We get the whole staff together and I run through 150 clips in a row to explain. This is the offense he played within. These are some of the things he is capable of. This is what our offense is able to do with this type of player. And from that meeting on....the meeting ends...everyone discusses. We have these analytic charts that show people in free agency who have the best ability to separate, YAC stuff, and the whole organization saw it and moved forward to empower Tua.

I called Tua in. Showed him the same tape. Anyone that was willing to listen, I wanted to make sure they knew.

When Tua saw it, what did he say?
It was the most extreme case of a person not knowing how to take a compliment. You could tell he was not used to anything but overly constructive negativity. It was a slow momentum building meeting. Probably at clip 75, he was reading the room and realizing this was not a setup. He starts to sit up in his chair and starts participating. I tell him you are doing all this incredible stuff, and in my estimation people are not open enough. I show him what it should look like. I cut in some 49er clips. And by the end he is like, we need playmakers!"

I loved reading this bit. It’s good insight into strong leadership in terms of building consensus/communicating vision and getting buy in. Not easy in any professional. Well done coach McCoach
 
GM's are people just like you.......they just have more information on players......you could do just as good or better than any other GM's.......people think GM are perfect just because they work for an NFL team but again, they're just regular people that make mistakes just like us.
There ain't nobody I ever knew that was quite like this GM. Just sayin.
 
anyone else pickup on the fact that his first year, in FA FO wanted to beef up OL and McD WRs? Since McD got his way last year, points again to the idea that McD must be a big influence in them not spending $$$ on the OL this year. And the way he described his disagreement with them was like he was the one calling the shots, that he didn't want to tell them, 'because I'm the boss and I said so'. This would be quite noteworthy to confirm. Can't argue with that philosophy last year but this year I strongly disagree.
 
Last edited:
anyone else pickup on the fact that his first year, in FA FO wanted to beef up OL and McD WRs? Since McD got his way last year, points again to the idea that McD must be a big influence in them not spending $$$ on the OL. This would be quite noteworthy to confirm.
I noticed and I agree with him.
 
Great video. Helluva lot more informative and entertaining than watching a gruff Bill Bellichick give 58 minutes of non-answers at a Patriots press conference.
Whenever I see Spiketex post I think of the nasty guy on Mad Max with the wild hairdo that looks like a spike! Ha ha just an cookoo observation from the cheap seats… I’m sure Spiketex is a very handsome fellow! (Insert intro to @circumstances emoticon here)
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom