Samphin said:Ronnie Brown, hands down!
Gunner4u65 said:Hey Boomer,
That has to propel him into the top 5 eh? I think just that fact that he ran at the combine will raise his stock even further. I no longer have any doubts(not that I had many) that Brown is worthy of the #2 pick in the draft when compared to the other talent available in this years draft. Now if we can con a 1st out of someone for Surtain(not likely), we could pick up another solid player to fill another need. if we get a mid second rounder for Pat and we take Ronnie #2, who do you think would be a good pick up in round 2? My guess could be either a safety(Shazor?), a QB (Cambell?) or a second tier Dlineman(Swancutt?)
I didnt even see your post but we are right on the same wavelength there.cnyphinfan said:Let's not get carried away. There have been plenty of speed guys that have amounted to crap as running backs. There is more to look at then speed.
not to mention the fresh tread on his tires:eek:General Tso said:Brown is faster, a better receiver, a better blocker, has played better against top competition in big games, and has zero character concerns. He is the best RB in the draft.
The Brown comparison is awful in terms of running styles, but decent in terms of receiving skills. Westbrook and Faulk are shiftier backs without a lot of power... Brown is more of a one cut and explode back who can break the big runs and pick up the short yardage plays. I think the Tomlinson/Dillon mix is a more accurate comparison (Dillon running style with Tomlinson receiving skills).Hostile7 said:Those comparisons are awful.
Brown= Brian Westbrook+ Marshall Fualk . May or may not be an everydown back, but is a great receiver and can run more complicated routes.
Benson= Edge + Ricky. Shifty in the open field and when finding holes, shows great balance and vision, with the extra gear to turn it up when going to the outside.
Williams= Curtis Martin + LT. Great vision, keeps his legs moving, balanced, and has surprising power for his size.
Hostile7 said:Those comparisons are awful.
Brown= Brian Westbrook+ Marshall Fualk . May or may not be an everydown back, but is a great receiver and can run more complicated routes.
Benson= Edge + Ricky. Shifty in the open field and when finding holes, shows great balance and vision, with the extra gear to turn it up when going to the outside.
Williams= Curtis Martin + LT. Great vision, keeps his legs moving, balanced, and has surprising power for his size.
Your point is well taken...BUT..those other guys (Like John Avery) for example were speedsters who played RB..this is a different case with Brown..he's clearly a very capable RB who happens to have great speed..this was the only question mark on him..and he's come trhoughcnyphinfan said:Let's not get carried away. There have been plenty of speed guys that have amounted to crap as running backs. There is more to look at then speed.