Most underrated/overrated Dolphins of all time? | Page 2 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Most underrated/overrated Dolphins of all time?

Underrated:
Adewale “Wale” Ogunleye - had 9.5 sacks in 2002 and followed up with 15 sacks in 2003. Was a good run defender and nice bookend for Jason Taylor.

Lamar Smith - his vision to find little creases in the line and hit the hole was amazing. Just a good solid running back with a once in a lifetime playoff performance to beat the Colts, 40 carries for 209 yards. Too bad Wannstedt had run him ragged and we got blanked by the Raiders.

Overrated:
Jeff Cross - Never seen a player more epitomize “looks like Tarzan, plays like Jane.” No football awareness, and could never get to the quarterback.

Jamar Fletcher - He was a marked man when we took him in round 1 instead of Reggie Wayne, Chad Johnson, oh, and some guy named DREW BREES. I will never forgive Wannstedt for that.
 
AJ Duhe said:
Underrated:
Adewale “Wale” Ogunleye - had 9.5 sacks in 2002 and followed up with 15 sacks in 2003. Was a good run defender and nice bookend for Jason Taylor.

Lamar Smith - his vision to find little creases in the line and hit the hole was amazing. Just a good solid running back with a once in a lifetime playoff performance to beat the Colts, 40 carries for 209 yards. Too bad Wannstedt had run him ragged and we got blanked by the Raiders.

Overrated:
Jeff Cross - Never seen a player more epitomize “looks like Tarzan, plays like Jane.” No football awareness, and could never get to the quarterback.

Jamar Fletcher - He was a marked man when we took him in round 1 instead of Reggie Wayne, Chad Johnson, oh, and some guy named DREW BREES. I will never forgive Wannstedt for that.
Click to expand...
Jamar fletcher overrated? Lmao dude isn’t rated at all. He sucked.
 
Overrated:
(Coach) Jimmuh Johnson... just a travesty that this slimy cretin followed the great one.
(Player) Reshad Jones... Maybe the worst contract that we've ever handed out.

Underrated:
(Coach) Don Shula... whatever we've said about him; it isn't enough.
(Player) Rusty Chambers... a waiver wire UDFA, this guy became the leader of our entire defense. He died on a car crash at 27.
 
Feverdream said:
Overrated:
(Coach) Jimmuh Johnson... just a travesty that this slimy cretin followed the great one.
(Player) Reshad Jones... Maybe the worst contract that we've ever handed out.

Underrated:
(Coach) Don Shula... whatever we've said about him; it isn't enough.
(Player) Rusty Chambers... a waiver wire UDFA, this guy became the leader of our entire defense. He died on a car crash at 27.
Click to expand...
 
Over Rated - Vontae Davis, Randy McMichael, Randall Hill,
Under Rated - Channing Crowder, Brian Cox, Chris Chambers, Marco Coleman.
 
Underrated:
Chad Pennington
Trace Armstrong
Reggie Roby
John Offerdahl
Marc Trestman
Arepas


Overrated:
Brandon Marshall
Richmond Webb (run blocking was awful)
Raekwon Davis
Louis Oliver
Andy Cohen
#FinsUp
 
Underated - Agree with you guys that said Yeremiah Bell and Brian Hartline. Hartline had an incredible ability to tap his toes on sideline catches and he was all heart.

Overated - Surprised nobody has said Suh. Or maybe he was just overpaid. I'll throw in Channing Crowder and Bobby McCain. Neither were useless by any means. But both held onto starting jobs for a little too long simply because we had nothing better.
 
Underrated
Howard Twilley
Mercury Morris
Jake Scott
Nat Moore
Zach Thomas
John Offerdahl

Overrated
Larry Csonka
Jim Kiick
Garo Yepremiam
Nick Buonticotti
Mark Clayton
Mark Duper
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom