Sounds like we're not as far apart as I initially thought. You're right...Beck was a terrible bust and it will take some time for Pat White to adjust from a shotgun spread offense to an NFL offense.
For the record, I was a big believer in Carey and I thought that he was being unfairly judged and part of his problem was the coaching staff itself. Carey has developed into a nice, it not outstanding player, and I'm happy he finally got a chance to show what he had.