I don't know what to say. Some games he had it, some games he didn't. I truely do believe the poor o-line play and weak receiver corpse played a big part in Jays slump, in 03' I think the neglection of the Offense by Wanny finally caught up with the dolphins.
If the line gets fixed up, and if Jay were to be named the starter. I think he'll do fine. I see glimpses of greatness from Jay... @ Dallas, Vs Washington, of 03'. If only he could be consistant with that kind of play he'd be a pretty good QB.
Unless Feeley blows Fiedler out of the water, I'd like to see Fiedler get just one more shot, with a decent offense. If he can't get it done with what we now have, then I will call it quits for Fiedler.