I agree with you. I think DVP is good as long as he stays healthy but I saw glimpses of Williams having a higher ceiling. I also think last years broken foot/ankle accident was the result of Wilkins landing on it in celebration of the TD.For now, I ABSOLUTELY keep them both... without a doubt, without a pause to think about it.
If PW remains healthy this year, I honestly believe he will surpass DVP's performance and this question will answer itself, but as I have said many times, he does have to remain healthy and prove that those two injuries were a product of bad luck, rather than poor structure.
Right? He has 716 yards and 7TDs in 16 games. He has missed 16 games in 2 seasons due to injury. If you compare him to Parker over their careers he has caught roughly 9% less of his targets (than Parker).Am I the only one who thinks Williams is so over rated on this board? He has a few special catches otherwise he drops a ton of balls.