Fisher has done a better job w/o a doubt. Had Miami finished off this season and made the playoffs I'd give the edge to Philbin but they collapsed, SL plays in a much tougher division and he had less to work with. Fisher gets the edge
With out a doubt? Seriously?
Fisher and Philbin have done almost equal jobs, but Fisher definitely has not done a better job "without a doubt". Philbin started his career in Miami with a rookie quarterback, Fisher had a veteran quarterback. Philbin's team improved his record in his second season, Fisher's squad got worse.
I can give you maybe a toss up between the two, but Fisher hasn't done anything spectacular in St. Louis.