POLL: Who is/was the best Dolphins QB post-Marino? | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

POLL: Who is/was the best Dolphins QB post-Marino?

Who is/was the best Dolphins QB post-Marino?

  • Total voters
    232
  • Poll closed .
finsforce

finsforce

Practice Squad
Joined
Mar 13, 2006
Messages
236
Reaction score
0
Location
Melbourne, FL
Your choices are:

1. Jay Fiedler (2000-2004): Went 36-23 as a starter, including 21-10 during the 2000 and 2001 seasons.

2. Gus Frerotte (2005): Went 9-6 to highlight Nick Saban's first season as Dolphins coach.

3. Daunte Culpepper (2006): Went 1-3 before Dolphins shut him down for season with knee problems.

4. Joey Harrington (2006): Replaced Culpepper, going 5-6 in 11 games.

5. Trent Green (2007-?): A "wait-and-see" guy, but his career numbers are great.

6. One of the others (if it's even worth the time).
 
Jay Fiedler, not even close.

Green has not played a down and should not be in the poll.
 
Fiedler by a long shot...The last time we saw the playoffs was when he was QB and even though he wasnt the best, I miss not having a QB carousel every freakin year. He still has the 5th best winning percentage out of any active QB with a 25 start minimum. When he was starting for us I think he was 3rd or something behind Brady and Manning maybe
 
Hopefully, Green will become the best QB since Marino but he hasn't played for us yet. Fiedler takes the cake. As sad as that is.
 
Its gotta be Jay Fiedler and Green hasnt taken a snap as a fin so hes not considered
 
Fielder for sure. Eveyrone hates the guys for a lot of the bone-head mistakes he made but he was a winner. his record shows, all star defense or not.

his first couple seasons he really wasn't bad, not nearly as bad as people make him out to have been. he threw for like 3000 yards with chan gailey as the OC and lamar smith as the running back. he never had any real weapons till ricky, but by that time hip/thumb injuries had taken its toll.

Remember the sunday night Denver game where fielder broke his throwing hand thumb and kept playing, put us in position for mare to knock a 54 yarder in the snow storm? that was awesome, i think we were like 5-1 before that then lucas came in and stinked it up.
 
Fiedler, like moving from the Ritz Carlton into a cheap motel.:boohoo:
 
SamTodd said:
Fielder for sure. Eveyrone hates the guys for a lot of the bone-head mistakes he made but he was a winner. his record shows, all star defense or not.

his first couple seasons he really wasn't bad, not nearly as bad as people make him out to have been. he threw for like 3000 yards with chan gailey as the OC and lamar smith as the running back. he never had any real weapons till ricky, but by that time hip/thumb injuries had taken its toll.

Remember the sunday night Denver game where fielder broke his throwing hand thumb and kept playing, put us in position for mare to knock a 54 yarder in the snow storm? that was awesome, i think we were like 5-1 before that then lucas came in and stinked it up.
Click to expand...

And when we were playing Oakland and he took the snap, the coverage was great and he had to run and dive in from a ways out. The guy had guts man, guts. He was considered one of the best scrambling QB's when he played
 
That would be Fiedler, and it's not even close.

If Noodle Arm would have had an arm, he would have been excellent. Too bad we can't turn apples into oranges though.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom