Week 1 vs. Tennessee: Loss. (0-1). Tannehill mounts a comeback in the second half after a rusty first half. Morten Anderson, signed the day of the game due to the complete inability of the organization to find a capable field goal kicker, misses a chip shot as time expires, and the Fins lose 34-33. Despite a three-touchdown second half, Tannehill is berated by an exceptionally loud and angry minority who insists that a winner "would have picked up Anderson and thrown him over the crossbar."
Week 2 at New York Jets: Win (1-1). Baker Mayfield throws for 300 yards, 2 TDs and 3 picks, while Tannehill methodically leads a balanced attack for a 27-17 victory. Critics blast Tannehill for not having a gunslinger mentality.
Week 3 vs. Oakland: Win (2-1). Tannehill outduels Derek Carr 30-28. Critics immediately run to statistics to show how much further along Derek Carr is at this point in his career.
Week 4 at New England: Loss (2-2). The Patriots win 35-24, aided by a questionable fourth quarter penalty on Cam Wake, who is given a personal foul call for "Staring at Brady too intensely."
Week 5 at Cincinnati: Win (3-2). The Bengals fall to 1-4 after a 21-13 game, and Marvin Lewis laughs out loud at the postgame press conference when he's told that some view Adam Gase's third year as a make-or-break one. "Oh, head coaches get two years to turn a franchise around now? That's ******* hilarious."
Week 6 vs. Chicago: Win (4-2). The Dolphins eviscerate the Bears under a particularly hot October sun, 35-7. Mitch Trubisky literally bursts into flames due to their dark road unis. Undeterred, someone starts a "Would you take Mitch Trubisky over Tannehill even if he was actually on fire at the time?" thread.
Week 7 vs. Detroit: Win (5-2): The Dolphins fire on all cylinders, and win a close game 28-24. Peace and harmony exist on Finheaven for THREE WHOLE DAYS
Week 8 at Houston: Loss (5-3): Tannehill has a bad game, the Fins defense can't figure out Deshaun Watson, the Fins lose 38-10, and it's like a homecoming party for Tannehaters. They haven't been seen for nearly a month. Chaos reigns at Finheaven. Fishfanmiami finally snaps and bans 143 people in ten days, including himself.
Week 9 vs. New York Jets: Win (6-3): The Fins defense clicks after being torn up the previous week, and win a 9-6 squeaker in a monsoon when Uwe Von Schamann kicks an 18-yard FG as time expires. Immediately after the game, he re-retires and challenges Morten Andersen to a cage match.
Week 10 at Green Bay: Loss (6-4): Rodgers throws a 25-yard bullet to take a 38-34 lead with ten seconds left. There's nothing amusing here. I can totally see this happening.
Week 12 at Indianapolis: Win (7-4): Coming off a bye, the rested Dolphins travel to Indy and win 32-17. Andrew Luck has been cryogenically frozen, set to wake up in 10 years, when maybe someone can actually figure out what the **** is wrong with his shoulder.
Week 13 vs. Buffalo: Win (8-4): Making his first start in replacement of AJ McCarron, Sam Darnold throws 2 picks in the first half, and the Fins hold on to beat the Bills 17-13.
Week 14 vs. New England: Win (9-4): The Fins defense continues to improve, holding Brady and the Patriots to 250 total yards of offense, and the Fins win 34-17. The playoff bandwagon is in full swing, and several desperate "Remember, Tannehill has never led the Dolphins to the playoffs!" threads pop up.
Week 15 at Minnesota: Loss (9-5): Minnesota completely shuts down the Fins in a raucous home-field drubbing, 28-7. Again, nothing amusing here. I could totally see this happening.
Week 16 vs. Jacksonville: Win (10-5): In one of the more impassioned games of the past decade, the Dolphins come from behind to win, 21-20 in the last 30 seconds of the game. Revelry ensues as the Dolphins secure their second playoff berth in three years.
Week 17 at Buffalo: Loss (10-6): Locked into the fifth seed, the Fins have nothing to gain or lose, and send out backup QB Kurt Benkert for his first NFL start. After a shaky start, he leads an improbable comeback, but falls just short as the Bills win 21-20. Simultaneous threads suggesting to trade Tannehill are started before the game ends.