ghostface95
Starter
Fair - means meets expectations.
Rodgers sat for three years and was 6-10 in his last fourth year of the rookie contract.
That, does not meet expectations of a first round quarterback or any expectations of good quarterbacking for four years. That is unfair.
Pulling stuff out of thin air is unfair. Rodgers is a second-contract quarterback, that is a fact.
In 2008 Rodgers 4th year of his rookie contract (1st as starting QB) the Packers went to the playoffs and lost to AZ.
Coincidentally, they lost off a Dansby INT pick 6; thus signing said player in 2009 off-season FA.