Salguero - Neither Rosen Or Fitzpatrick Will Be The Dolphins Long Term Quarterback | Page 13 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

Salguero - Neither Rosen Or Fitzpatrick Will Be The Dolphins Long Term Quarterback

Rosen is not a downgrade from Tannehill lol nice agenda
 
ckparrothead said:
It takes a Dolphins fan to watch what Josh Rosen did last year and watch what Ryan Tannehill did last year and decide Rosen was better. That's dedication.
Click to expand...

Right now, absolutely. I can't see how you can view it any other way. With that being said this could change, many consider Rosen the better prospect but based on NFL football in 2018 Tannehill is better.

I don't wish injury on anyone but it will be interesting to see Tannehill in Tennessee WHEN Mariota gets hurt. I'm not a Mariota fan at all and always felt Tannehill was better BUT realize it could have been my aqua and orange colored glasses. Nonetheless nobody will ever convince me the Titans were or are any closer to a championship with Mariota then we ever were with Tannehill.
 
DolfanISS said:
Right now, absolutely. I can't see how you can view it any other way. With that being said this could change, many consider Rosen the better prospect but based on NFL football in 2018 Tannehill is better.

I don't wish injury on anyone but it will be interesting to see Tannehill in Tennessee WHEN Mariota gets hurt. I'm not a Mariota fan at all and always felt Tannehill was better BUT realize it could have been my aqua and orange colored glasses. Nonetheless nobody will ever convince me the Titans were or are any closer to a championship with Mariota then we ever were with Tannehill.
Click to expand...


I don’t think you are gonna have to wait for Mariota to get hurt.
 
DolfanISS said:
Right now, absolutely. I can't see how you can view it any other way. With that being said this could change, many consider Rosen the better prospect but based on NFL football in 2018 Tannehill is better.

I don't wish injury on anyone but it will be interesting to see Tannehill in Tennessee WHEN Mariota gets hurt. I'm not a Mariota fan at all and always felt Tannehill was better BUT realize it could have been my aqua and orange colored glasses. Nonetheless nobody will ever convince me the Titans were or are any closer to a championship with Mariota then we ever were with Tannehill.
Click to expand...

I don't really want to comment on Mariota. I'm just saying that last year Josh Rosen was quite possibly the worst quarterback in football, and Tannehill, while not good, was not that.

It's a hell of a lot closer to being controversial to say that Fitzpatrick wasn't better than Tannehill, than it is Rosen.
 
I assume he has an inside source, but seems too early to make that determination. Plus, I doubt Miami would want that information out there. Play your cards close to the vest so to speak.
 
andyahs said:
Are you blaming him if we only win 2-3?
Click to expand...
No, because the roster's talent level isn't capable of winning more than that.

What I'll be looking at is how competitive we are, how we respond to adversity, and whether we look like we're better near the end of the season compared to the beginning. The last couple coaches we've had clearly spent the season getting out-coached which is why we would always limp to the finish line.
 
If Jamies Winston was waiting on the bench, tannehill would have got benched likely as many times if not more than fitzy

Edit: and I don’t think he would have earned it back the way fitzy did a time or two, either
 
ckparrothead said:
Do they give you extra points on the scoreboard because you're playing a younger guy? Is there a handicap I'm not aware of?
Click to expand...
Lol Maybe you guys are on some type of topic that I’m not aware of but if your comparing Tanni to Rosen I just think it’s unfair to do that based on last years performance
 
Manning said:
Lol Maybe you guys are on some type of topic that I’m not aware of but if your comparing Tanni to Rosen I just think it’s unfair to do that based on last years performance
Click to expand...

First step is admitting it. Second step might be bothering to read up and see what people are talking about before going off half-****ed at someone.
 
ckparrothead said:
Do they give you extra points on the scoreboard because you're playing a younger guy? Is there a handicap I'm not aware of?
Click to expand...
Rosen has much better pocket awareness you can see that. Compare Tannehill as a rookie to Rosen as a rookie if you want a fair comp. But I know you don't you hated Rosen day 1 of that trade
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom