Like we don't have enough debates about our questionable QB we start debateing if Drew Bledsoe is a good qb. I think you find the same answer to both questions if you look objectively. They both can make bad judegements with the ball, and throw to many ints, but both are better than the other options the 2 teams have at QB. Neither of them can put their team on their back consistently, but both of them could lead a solid team to many victories. Both are feirce competitors, and quality people that gain the respect of their teamates. Jay may not have the arm stength, but he makes up for it with his mobility and ability to create on the move. Drew may not have the mobility, but he makes up for it with his arm strength. When you ask the question of who is better it can't be answered, because neither of them can take over a season like a Farve or a Mcnabb. Only thier teamates can detirmine who has the better record.