So..Ronnie got hurt huh?

[NawlinsBucFan]

I wasn't happy to hear that, but I find it interesting that when Carnell got hurt, it was because he was 'overused' and fragile, but obviously not so with Ronnie.

Truth is, they both got hurt for the same reason......s**t happens.

But for those of you keeping score at home:
RB-Ronnie Brown, #2 overall pick- 886 yards rushing in 14 games
RB-Carnell Williams, #5 overall pick- 1097 yards rushing in 13 games

And there were at 2 games in the middle of the season, where Carnell had to be pulled after the first quarter, that still count as games played. The bulk of those yards came in 11 games.

:D Just sayin'

 

[Tar Phin]

Carnell isn't playing with a guy named "Ricky Williams" on his team.

 

[phinfan2003]

I wasn't happy to hear that, but I find it interesting that when Carnell got hurt, it was because he was 'overused' and fragile, but obviously not so with Ronnie.

Truth is, they both got hurt for the same reason......s**t happens.

But for those of you keeping score at home:
RB-Ronnie Brown, #2 overall pick- 886 yards rushing in 14 games
RB-Carnell Williams, #5 overall pick- 1097 yards rushing in 13 games

And there were at 2 games in the middle of the season, where Carnell had to be pulled after the first quarter, that still count as games played. The bulk of those yards came in 11 games.

:D Just sayin'

I believe that Caddie will be Offensive ROY. Especially since his team is in the playoffs.

 

[Fin-Loco]

I don't even think Ronnie got hurt. I think it was a marketing strategy to put Ricky on display against a poor run defense!

 

[RunningBackGuru]

Ronnie would have MUCH better stats if he carried the full load every week.

 

[Winbaby#23]

I wasn't happy to hear that, but I find it interesting that when Carnell got hurt, it was because he was 'overused' and fragile, but obviously not so with Ronnie.

Truth is, they both got hurt for the same reason......s**t happens.

But for those of you keeping score at home:
RB-Ronnie Brown, #2 overall pick- 886 yards rushing in 14 games
RB-Carnell Williams, #5 overall pick- 1097 yards rushing in 13 games

And there were at 2 games in the middle of the season, where Carnell had to be pulled after the first quarter, that still count as games played. The bulk of those yards came in 11 games.

:D Just sayin'

Ronnie is still an all around better talent. After all is said and done at the end of there careers Ronnie will be the better back.

 

[PhiNomina]

Loom at the yards per carry AND receiving yards and Ronnie has more production per touch than Caddy.

I think they are both amazing backs and hope both have great careers. Just saying that Caddy gets the ball a TON more than Ronnie so he is going to have more yards, its a misleading stat.

 

[Tar Phin]

Ronnie YPC: 4.5
Carnell YPC: 4.1

 

[DolphinzD]

:sleep:

Ahh yes, here we go again with the Caddy/Ronnie debate. I knew it was only a matter of time before one of these threads popped up again.

 

[NJFINSFAN1]

I don't even think Ronnie got hurt. I think it was a marketing strategy to put Ricky on display against a poor run defense!

We all saw him get hurt during the game!:eek:

 

[BenchFiedler]

What is your point? or conclusion?

I want both rookies to contribute and have success with their teams.

This is very idiotic to come on a phins board to plea your case about Cadillac having more yards in less games than Ronnie just to get a cookie...:shakeno:

 

[KyPhinfan13]

I wasn't happy to hear that, but I find it interesting that when Carnell got hurt, it was because he was 'overused' and fragile, but obviously not so with Ronnie.

Truth is, they both got hurt for the same reason......s**t happens.

But for those of you keeping score at home:
RB-Ronnie Brown, #2 overall pick- 886 yards rushing in 14 games
RB-Carnell Williams, #5 overall pick- 1097 yards rushing in 13 games

And there were at 2 games in the middle of the season, where Carnell had to be pulled after the first quarter, that still count as games played. The bulk of those yards came in 11 games.

:D Just sayin'

Please go away.

 

[WharfRat]

I wasn't happy to hear that, but I find it interesting that when Carnell got hurt, it was because he was 'overused' and fragile, but obviously not so with Ronnie.

Truth is, they both got hurt for the same reason......s**t happens.

But for those of you keeping score at home:
RB-Ronnie Brown, #2 overall pick- 886 yards rushing in 14 games
RB-Carnell Williams, #5 overall pick- 1097 yards rushing in 13 games

And there were at 2 games in the middle of the season, where Carnell had to be pulled after the first quarter, that still count as games played. The bulk of those yards came in 11 games.

:D Just sayin'

It would be more accurate to insert total carries, and total carries by other RB's on the two teams...


Let's see... Caddy had 268 carries, as compared to Ronnie with 199, and Ricky with 140..... :hmmm: who was Caddy splitting carries with again?

 

[nlp0121]

I wasn't happy to hear that, but I find it interesting that when Carnell got hurt, it was because he was 'overused' and fragile, but obviously not so with Ronnie.

Truth is, they both got hurt for the same reason......s**t happens.

But for those of you keeping score at home:
RB-Ronnie Brown, #2 overall pick- 886 yards rushing in 14 games
RB-Carnell Williams, #5 overall pick- 1097 yards rushing in 13 games

And there were at 2 games in the middle of the season, where Carnell had to be pulled after the first quarter, that still count as games played. The bulk of those yards came in 11 games.

:D Just sayin'

Ronnie could've played, but Saban said it would be better to rest it.
Caddy has 69 more carries than Ronnie....about 3 games worth...
Ronnie splits time with Ricky.
Both are incredible talents, but they don't need to be compared because their situations are very different.

ADMIN EDIT: no need to get antagonistic
Just sayin

:dolphins::dolphins::dolphins::dolphins::dolphins::dolphins::dolphins:

 

[KyPhinfan13]

I don't even think Ronnie got hurt. I think it was a marketing strategy to put Ricky on display against a poor run defense!

Love the sig.........