arsenal said:everyones opinion is differnt, some will say they do compare, some will say they dont...
http://proxy.espn.go.com/nfl/draft05/news/story?id=2023594
Oh, I've seen the opinion repeated. My point is that whenever anybody actually compares the grades it doesn't come out that way. If people keep saying that last year's QB are rated higher then they should be able to point to some rating to prove that. If you don't have a rating then you're going by memory which is very unreliable. Last year I repeatedly defended the top 3 QBs as being worthy 1st rounders and now everybody claims they had no question marks. This is simply false. I've done searches and almost no sites actually keep last year grades on their posted on their site. The two (now) that I've seen show this year's QB rated about as high as everyone but Roth.