Well, based on my spotty memory and being a fan through only the 90s and 00s, these games stick out to me. All of them are mentioned before, but why not mention them again?
1) The Monday Night Massacre. I stayed up until 1 AM on a school night for that? Somehow Arnold Schwarzenegger calls the comeback AND the presidential election correctly that night. He should have given us lotto numbers as well. Well, he just happened to be a Republican Jets fan, but still...
2+3) Those games a couple years back against Minnesota and New England where the Fins just had to win to get in the playoffs. Thankfully, I slept through all but the last 2 minutes of the Minnesota game, but unfortunately, I sat through that New England game. I was glad that the Jets won and knocked the Dolphins out of the playoffs after that. I really didn't need to suffer through another Dolphins playoff blowout.
4) The Dolphins-Bills AFC Championship game. I was there, and the best part was when my mom got me an ice cream float. Wasn't this the same year when they blew out the Chargers in that monsoon? I miss that game because of the low visibility on the road, but I get to see this.
5) The 62-7 loss. It's the Dolphins in the playoffs, and it's over after the first quarter. It's Dan Marino's final game, and he might as well have just let Jay Fiedler play and take the fall.