Who Are the 50 Best Miami Dolphins Players of All Time?
- Thread starter Fin Fan in Cali
- Start date
I am not old enough to know some of those older players but I would put Josh Rosen in the top 20 right behind Jesse Davis.
Brother this is the best of list.
Suh? Seriously? No.
And I'd put Csonka ahead of Marino for two simple reasons: two Super Bowl rings.
And I'd put Csonka ahead of Marino for two simple reasons: two Super Bowl rings.
Ndamukong Suh Career Stats - NFL - ESPN
Complete career NFL stats for Philadelphia Eagles Defensive Tackle Ndamukong Suh on ESPN. Includes scoring, rushing, defensive and receiving stats.
I can understand on your post on Csonka.
Fun list.
I'd have Surtain ahead of Madison and Howard because I know damn well if all 3 were 22 years old and I could choose one, it would be #23.
Talent wise, Ricky Williams is top 15 I'd not top 10 but this list is weighted toward career accomplishment. Again, using the draft analog, if these guys are all eligible for the draft next year, you'd have a hard time coming up with 10 guys going ahead of RW.
Speaking of guys who you'd consider taking over Ricky Williams, Tim Bowens at #50? Uhhhhh no.
Cam Wake at 18? OK I can live with it but again, find me 10 players you'd draft over him.
I'd have Surtain ahead of Madison and Howard because I know damn well if all 3 were 22 years old and I could choose one, it would be #23.
Talent wise, Ricky Williams is top 15 I'd not top 10 but this list is weighted toward career accomplishment. Again, using the draft analog, if these guys are all eligible for the draft next year, you'd have a hard time coming up with 10 guys going ahead of RW.
Speaking of guys who you'd consider taking over Ricky Williams, Tim Bowens at #50? Uhhhhh no.
Cam Wake at 18? OK I can live with it but again, find me 10 players you'd draft over him.
Last edited:
- Joined
- May 27, 2005
- Messages
- 25,152
- Reaction score
- 34,856
Just shows how great this organization has been. I know it's been mostly rough since Don Shula retired, but this is a great list of players.
I would have to go through it in more detail, but I think Paul Warfield should be higher. He meant so much to those early 70's teams. Without his speed and big play ability, defenses might have been able to slow down Larry Csonka, Mercury Morris and Jim Kiick. Warfield also defined "team player," as he was the epitome of unselfish.
I would have to go through it in more detail, but I think Paul Warfield should be higher. He meant so much to those early 70's teams. Without his speed and big play ability, defenses might have been able to slow down Larry Csonka, Mercury Morris and Jim Kiick. Warfield also defined "team player," as he was the epitome of unselfish.
If Tua is not on this list, the list is shizz.
The best QB since Marino. Sorry Bob Griese. The record book is still open. If Tua isn’t on the list, the list is shizz.
The best QB since Marino. Sorry Bob Griese. The record book is still open. If Tua isn’t on the list, the list is shizz.
WCUPUNK
Club Member
Randy Starks and Reshad Jones not being on the list is criminal. Can also make a strong case for Jake Long considering his elite play for four years.
No way.
Who’s at 34?
It’s a really good list, but Sam Madison gets overrated a little on these lists. I think Trace Armstrong deserves consideration for the list.
Scrap
Go Fins
For their individual performance AS A DOLPHIN PLAYER, I’ll take Bowens over Suh. Then again, I disagree with a lot of the order of this list.
Good list!
I would second the comments about Trace Armstrong and Jake Long.......
I would second the comments about Trace Armstrong and Jake Long.......
BEANTOWNFINFAN
Active Roster
- Joined
- Aug 8, 2003
- Messages
- 662
- Reaction score
- 1,672
I think you have to have Richmond Webb in the top 10 and Ricky Williams in top 20