Fun list.
I'd have Surtain ahead of Madison and Howard because I know damn well if all 3 were 22 years old and I could choose one, it would be #23.
Talent wise, Ricky Williams is top 15 I'd not top 10 but this list is weighted toward career accomplishment. Again, using the draft analog, if these guys are all eligible for the draft next year, you'd have a hard time coming up with 10 guys going ahead of RW.
Speaking of guys who you'd consider taking over Ricky Williams, Tim Bowens at #50? Uhhhhh no.
Cam Wake at 18? OK I can live with it but again, find me 10 players you'd draft over him.