Zach Wilson or Justin Fields at 3? Any issues?

[foozool13]

Assume Miami takes Fields/Wilson at 3? Would anyone be against that? Can never have enough good players at the most important position in the NFL. I was all aboard the Tua train pre draft last year, but man does he look “small” in the NFL. With the quality of coaching we have with Flores it’s highly unlikely we pick this high again with this regime. I would do it and I hope we take him.

If anything u can trade the other one worst case scenario for a 1st again.

Edit: My point here is you take a top QB prospect and let them compete same as you would any other position in the NFL.

Edit 2: This pick is an ultra luxury pick, why not use it at the most important position in the NFL. What’s the downside? You still have 3 more great picks to build around these 2 QBs.

If our scouting thinks either of these guys have what it take to be a NFL championship caliber QB, we should take them. No questions asked.

 

[Nublar7]

It is a waste of resources to take another quarterback. They have to, and will, use their picks to bolster the offense around Tua. Not replace him

 

[Phinatic8u]

Well for one Zach Wilson sucks so I'd be pretty pissed off.

 

[Schleprock]

Oh yaaa, another QB whisperer and hot take thread....definitely needed.

 

[Gonzofinfan]

Oh yaaa, another QB whisperer and hot take thread....definitely needed.

ADAM GASE IS THAT YOU?

 

[realdolphin]

I´d take him, we are almost set in every other position and we have another 1st rounder and more picks. TUA is not showing anything to feel we are set at QB, he needs competition.

 

[crashfan]

I would be for Wilson getting picked at number 3, with a trove of draft picks going the dolphins way from another team.

 

[RobertHorry]

19

30

240

63.3

8.0

1

1

Thats his stats vs Costal Carolina.

But for the Dolphins he will elevate Navy Option QB and Kentucky QB!

 

[foozool13]

Oh yaaa, another QB whisperer and hot take thread....definitely needed.

So you’re the whisper and think Tua is that dude huh?

 

[LargoFin]

If Lawrence is off the board, and they take Wilson at 3, Im okay with that. But he is not Lawrence or Herbert or this year's Allen, or Mahomes. Wilson is just incremental improvement over Tua, bigger, more mobile, stronger arm.

 

[Phinatic8u]

19

30

240

63.3

8.0

1

1

Thats his stats vs Costal Carolina.

But for the Dolphins he will elevate Navy Option QB and Kentucky QB!

For the record that college is in the shithole we call Dirty Myrtle!.

 

[ChambersChamps]

Well for one Zach Wilson sucks so I'd be pretty pissed off.

This. This

 

[superphin]

But what if he doesn't impress all the experts in 9 games as rookie? Do we draft another QB the following year?

 

[PFC]

Wilson would be a great addition.

 

[RobertHorry]

But what if doesn't impress all the experts in 9 games as rookie? Do we draft another QB the following year?

No we trade entire draft for Herbert!!!