Gase did an impressive job coaching the team in 2016. He did a not so impressive job in 2017 and he is doing a not so impressive job right now.
I think to go back now with the benefit of hindsight and rip on people for posting positive things about a first year coach who went 10-6 with an injury depleted roster is kind of cherry picking it a little bit.
I have to assume some were MORE IMPRESSED than others...