QB heavy offseason | Page 5 | FinHeaven - Miami Dolphins Forums

QB heavy offseason

Forgot about Heupel. I thought we drafted Druckenmiller then traded him to SF? You could be right, I probably have it mixed up.

But all that goes back to the crux of the problem. We dont invest quality draft picks into the QB spot, and in the few times we did, we picked poorly. Pat White was the biggest headscratcher of them all.

Beck was already like 28 years old when we drafted him, and Henne....well....i'll just. leave. that. one. alone....

He got drafted by SF, and they traded him to us in like 1999 I think. Long time ago, my memory's a bit hazy, but I think that's how it went down. Pat White was a head-scratcher, because it seems we drafted him only to run the Wildcat (or WildPat, durrhurrhurr) offense, which made no sense, as the league had it all figured out by teh end of the 2008 offense.

Beck was an old man, and with Cameron out, didn't fit the team's plans. Henne...I'll admit, I saw some potential in the kid...thought he could be something, especially after that Jets game in 2009, but man, he really hit a wall and hit it hard.

You're absolutely right though, it was our problem, and it'll continue to be a problem. Look at the issues we ran into with Wannstache. We had Fiedler, Fiedler was his guy, and nothing was going to move him from it. I think Matt Hasselbeck was originally his target, but, Seattle came in and took him from us (Damn you Mike Holmgren), but we never tried to upgrade, other than bringing in some also-rans as backups, such as Ray Lucas or Brian Griese, and it really cost us, especially with the great defense we had during that time, and the awesome run game we had too.

We'll run into problems if we don't draft and develop another QB now, too. I'd draft one every year if I could, if only to spin him off to get a high draft pick (or two or three) to a QB needy team, like the Falcons did with Schaub...or the Packers did all those years with Ron Wolf running things. Sooner or later, time's going to catch up with Tannehill, and we need to have a solid transition plan in place.
 
But all that goes back to the crux of the problem. We dont invest quality draft picks into the QB spot, and in the few times we did, we picked poorly. Pat White was the biggest headscratcher of them all.

Miami and NE have drafted exactly the same number of QBs in the first round - 3 each.

Miami - Griese, Marino, Tannehill
NE - Plunkett, Eason, Bledsoe

Just thought that was interesting.
 
Im home sick, so ive got the time to do some digging. Went to this site and complied a list of EVERY QB ever drafted by the Fins. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/teams/mia/draft.htm

Interesting stuff. You can see when we stopped drafting QBs and where our QB troubles became apparent. Make of it what you will:

Year Rnd Player Pick Pos To

1966 1 Rick Norton 2 QB 1970
1967 1 Bob Griese HOF 4 QB 1980
1968 6 Kim Hammond 142 QB 1969
1971 4 Joe Theismann 99 QB 1985
1972 8 Craig Curry 207 QB
1973 5 Don Strock 111 QB 1988
1974 10 Gary Valbuena 260 QB
1975 14 John Graham 361 QB
1976 17 Jeff Grantz 480 QB
1978 12 Bill Kenney 333 QB 1988
1978 2 Guy Benjamin 51 QB 1983
1979 12 Larry Fortner 327 QB
1980 8 David Woodley 214 QB 1985
1981 4 Brad Wright 96 QB
1983 1 Dan Marino HOF 27 QB 1999
1984 5 Dean May 138 QB 1987
1986 10 Jeff Wickersham 274 QB
1987 12 Jim Karsatos 322 QB
1988 7 Kerwin Bell 180 QB 1996
1990 4 Scott Mitchell 93 QB 2001
1992 11 Mark Barsotti 296 QB
1998 6 John Dutton 172 QB
2001 6 Josh Heupel 177 QB
2007 2 John Beck 40 QB 2011
2008 2 Chad Henne 57 QB 2017
2009 2 Pat White 44 QB 2009
2012 1 Ryan Tannehill 8 QB 2016
2016 7 Brandon Doughty 223 QB
 
Theismann, forgot we drafted him...he went the CFL route before going to Washington didn’t he?

Yep, another reason I like the Giants.

giphy.gif
 
Im home sick, so ive got the time to do some digging. Went to this site and complied a list of EVERY QB ever drafted by the Fins. https://www.pro-football-reference.com/teams/mia/draft.htm

Interesting stuff. You can see when we stopped drafting QBs and where our QB troubles became apparent. Make of it what you will:

Year Rnd Player Pick Pos To

1966 1 Rick Norton 2 QB 1970
1967 1 Bob Griese HOF 4 QB 1980
1968 6 Kim Hammond 142 QB 1969
1971 4 Joe Theismann 99 QB 1985
1972 8 Craig Curry 207 QB
1973 5 Don Strock 111 QB 1988
1974 10 Gary Valbuena 260 QB
1975 14 John Graham 361 QB
1976 17 Jeff Grantz 480 QB
1978 12 Bill Kenney 333 QB 1988
1978 2 Guy Benjamin 51 QB 1983
1979 12 Larry Fortner 327 QB
1980 8 David Woodley 214 QB 1985
1981 4 Brad Wright 96 QB
1983 1 Dan Marino HOF 27 QB 1999
1984 5 Dean May 138 QB 1987
1986 10 Jeff Wickersham 274 QB
1987 12 Jim Karsatos 322 QB
1988 7 Kerwin Bell 180 QB 1996
1990 4 Scott Mitchell 93 QB 2001
1992 11 Mark Barsotti 296 QB
1998 6 John Dutton 172 QB
2001 6 Josh Heupel 177 QB
2007 2 John Beck 40 QB 2011
2008 2 Chad Henne 57 QB 2017
2009 2 Pat White 44 QB 2009
2012 1 Ryan Tannehill 8 QB 2016
2016 7 Brandon Doughty 223 QB

Here is a very good draft site. You can browse by team, round, position and combinations.

http://drafthistory.com
 
Just been thinking about this. I think there are ten QB's that could be considered for a starting gig this offseason with a new team, including the draft:
Cousins, Keenam, Bridgewater, Bradford, Foles, McCarren, Mayfield, Rosen, Allen, Darnold

I think there are seven teams looking to add one of these players:
Cleveland, Jets, Buffalo, Denver, Minnesota, Arizona, Giants

How do you think it plays out? Have I missed anyone?
 
Just been thinking about this. I think there are ten QB's that could be considered for a starting gig this offseason with a new team, including the draft:
Cousins, Keenam, Bridgewater, Bradford, Foles, McCarren, Mayfield, Rosen, Allen, Darnold

I think there are seven teams looking to add one of these players:
Cleveland, Jets, Buffalo, Denver, Minnesota, Arizona, Giants

How do you think it plays out? Have I missed anyone?
There are several teams that could add based on below average incumbent or an aging star on a team that had missed playoffs. Add Cincy, Miami And SD
 
Pretty pathetic 3 2nd round qbs in a row that sucked. No qb’s drafted during Tannehill but multiple qb’s drafted during Marino era.
 
We haven't even seen the full market of backup level QBs yet. For example, if Denver signs Cousins, Trevor Siemian might be released. Siemian has enough talent and experience to qualify as a solid #2 option.

I would hope to sign a backup before the draft. That way, the front office doesn't feel any pressure to reach in the draft. In this scenario, the QB room is Tannehill, veteran #2, rookie #3, and if the rookie shows potential, the veteran backup could be dangled in a trade when someone's starter inevitably goes down.

Correct. There will be more QBs available (draft and FA) than there are QB-desperate teams and not all available QBs will be high demand starters. I'm inclined to think Miami will sign a vet QB, which, for the RT17 haters, will be their hoped for competition.
 
Back
Top Bottom