Keller
1) Can get down the seam - True, but he isn't very aware and isn't a good catcher of the ball, which are traits that cause a lot of incompletions, INT's and INT non-break-ups
2) Match up issue for the D - In between the 20's because of speed, yes. But, in the red zone his speed is irrelevant, his quickness minimized, his suspect hands magnified and his complete lack of size amplified. Not a red zone matchup problem at all.
3) Good inline blocker - I'm not convinced of this, but most receiving TE's are poor inline blockers so it's not a negative or positive, but if Keller is in the game, it's very likely a pass and the defense knows it
4) Takes away from the Jets - Non-issue for me because their passing game was/is impotent WITH Keller so whomever they replace him with I'd guess has a decent chance of being better. Plus, if he goes, so does his salary on their Salary Cap mismanaged team
I like Jared Cook too and he is just 25. I love the age factor. Keller will be 29 at the start of next year. I do not like that. - Good points and I also prefer Cook to Keller. But for me, Cook fails the test too. He has a good wingspan and size, is a decent blocker, but his loping style negates a bit of his size and quickness. More importantly, he's not a great receiver, so I feel he's sort of a Fasano version 1.2 at best, and I'm looking for a Gronkowski, Graham, Gonzales, or at the very least a Fasano 3.0 ... and Cook is one of those workout warriors with great measurables and lack of production because the skill is lacking IMHO