Fair points but don't you think we should wait a bit longer than just 9 starts before we decide he sucks?What people seem to ignore is that Fitz did a lot more with the same receivers and running backs.
It's too early to tell what kind of player Tua will become but the excuses for his sub par performance this past season are a bit mind boggling when even Tua himself basically said he sucked and needs to do a lot better.
It's not about eliminating excuses for Tua, it's about the kid actually doing more than the guy behind hin with the team he is a part of. Elite QBs elevate the game play of their teams...
The main thing here imo is that he was coming back from a horrible injury/major surgery while other rookies could concentrate on their game while Tua had to try to get healthy enough to play. Fitz could just go out there and let it fly all day. Why would he care? Nobody was expecting him to take the take to the playoffs since he's never done that in his career.
Lets give Tua at least his second year and see what happens.