As a prospect Tua was light-years ahead of Herbert coming out of college. Yes, the hip injury was a question mark. However, the only area Herbert beat out Tua in was arm strength. He was statistically not even a top 5 QB in his class in most categories when you broke down throws by distance and routes. Guys like Hurts and Love were ahead of him on the accuracy of numerous throws. Herbert might end up being a phenomenal NFL QB, but I feel like 95% of the people here would have been furious if we drafted him 5th overall. As a guy who enjoys “scouting” QB prospects his success last season was one of the bigger surprises I have had; I 100% didn’t think it would come together for him so fast.