This isn't a binary argument. There's a gray area where Rosen shows enough "promise" to maybe win a game or two and that's it. He doesn't turn out to be anything next year either, and now we don't have Tua.
It's hopeless my friend. No matter what you say it won't make a difference.
Miami has scouted Herbert numerous times since 2018. Whether that's a smoke screen or not, no one knows? But he appears to be highly thought of in Miami's F/O. Fromm IMHO is the better fit, in terms of what he does pre snap and post snap progression. He's not prototypical in terms of size, but he's super smart behind center. If Miami puts a really good offensive line in front of Fromm, they could win a lot of games. As for Herbert, I read something very interesting over the weekend about his frustration with Oregon's play calling. They've restricted his throwing to screens, bubble screens and flats, which is hampering the offense overall. Oregon hasn't allowed him to unleash his arm very often and he's become unhappy. It begs to question, Are the pro evaluators thinking he's got more to him, based on the restrictions? Does he have more upside than previously thought? There could be a silver lining in the way Oregon is using Herbert. Meaning he could turn out to be a HUGE Steal, when a pro team let's him play Unrestricted?
