PhinBeck
Perennial All-Pro
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2003
- Messages
- 4,863
- Reaction score
- 0
rafael said:Your argument is based on the assumption that Brees and AJ are equivalent players and that since the complementing parts may be receiving similar upgrades the results will be similar. I disagree b/c I disagree with the base assumption. I don't see AJ as a guy who can make the play on his own. That's what Brees did last year when the other parts didn't work (player or coaching error).
While I dont agree that you can compare the future success of a qb based on the success of another qb in similar situations as they are diff players. I disagree with your assumption as well. The fact that you dont see AJ creating is where your thinking is finite. Since the comparison was brees in 03 to AJ in 04, neither "created" Brees did create in 04, but that was the initial showing of that ability. So based on the orginal assumption, ypu proved his point, or at least validated the possibility.