LarryFinFan
Left So Fla, never the Fins...
Junc...don't worry...
Every year we Fins fans get anxious and have all kinds of optimism. We have a new regime and with it brings new hope. Our team is better than it was in the last few years...you know, addition by subtraction, however, it really remains to be seen what this team can do going forward.
QB: We still don't have the QB situation settled. Maybe Tanny is going to be the real deal this year and maybe it'll be next season or never... Maybe Garrard can battle back from his back surgery to be a competent QB again. Maybe he can do it physically, but doesn't fit the WCO. MMoore is a 1/2 season wonder times 2 at this point (productive half season for Carolina and a productive half season for us). Maybe he can be our gap guy before Tanny gets up to speed, but he also doesn't fit well in the WCO and will be learning a completely new offense from what he's run here or in Carolina...
Truth be told, you guys also have questions at QB. Sanchez has plateau'd and not really progressed since his rookie season. There are questions about his leadership ability in addition to his physical ability as a QB. He certainly didn't come thru for you guys last year. Tebow is an enigma. Will his presence hurt or help your squad. If Sanchez has a game or two that are not very good, it's likely he'll rescind back into his shell when you guys start chanting "TEBOW!" Tebow is a winner and has all the intangibles you could want in a football player, but is he really a QB ?? Can you depend on him to execute Sparano's offense if Sanchez is hurt or just folds again ?? The thing is, Foxy and crew dumbed down the offense and tailor it to Tebow's game....Can Sparano do the same ?? Will Rexy interfere and force changes ?? Remember, he's a bit on the hot seat as well...
Offensive and Defensive scheme changes: This is major negative for Miami in this conversation... Coyle will likely run a similar D to what we have been running under Nolan, but I don't think he's the same level DC as Nolan at this point. Cincy was a pretty stout D and we carry over a good portion of the group we had, but can they adjust quick enough to be successful and get back to where they were ?? Offensively, again the question goes back to the QB. If that turns out well, then can the WR group we have get the job done. We have a good #3 guy, a mediocre #2 guy and a bunch of unproven other guys... While Philbin's offense isn't predicated on having great WRs, it does require good ones...do we have that group and can they pick up the O quick enough?? Makes even me laugh when I hear talk that we are so much better than last year because Sparano is gone...maybe we are better off, but talent-wise, I'm not convinced we're a lot better than last year...and ultimately, that's what wins games...
You guys, on the other hand are settled in your D, but coming off a down year. You guys, like us last year, despite ranking fairly high in the defensive standings, weren't quite as good as your rankings indicated. Have you settled your pass rushing issues, the one thing that Rexy's D is centered around ?? I don't see major improvement in this offseason... Offensively, it appears you have blamed Sanchez' lack of success on your OC and took up with Sparano. Short term, it's a good move for you. He's good at moving the focus of the O away from your deficiencies, but you guys don't have the OL that you had a couple of years ago to run his ground and pound... As to the RBs, I'd also give us a very, very slight edge overall. I'd say that Bush is better than Greene, but not by much and because of the other things he brings to the table than his pure running ability. They are two very different backs and it's tough to compare them.
All the other non-sense about your team's melt down last season and what not is just that...nonsense. It can easily be fixed and for all of Tony's bad points, one of his good points is that his players love him and that should help that get straightened out. However, if it doesn't and you guys start to lose, it could be a long year...Especially with the TEBOW chants start...
All in all, you guys should have a better season and better team than us. We simply don't know how Philbin will bring this team together. Comparing it to last years' team is not a good gauge to go by. However, your team is closer to being what it was last year than ours is to being worse than it was last season.
Every year we Fins fans get anxious and have all kinds of optimism. We have a new regime and with it brings new hope. Our team is better than it was in the last few years...you know, addition by subtraction, however, it really remains to be seen what this team can do going forward.
QB: We still don't have the QB situation settled. Maybe Tanny is going to be the real deal this year and maybe it'll be next season or never... Maybe Garrard can battle back from his back surgery to be a competent QB again. Maybe he can do it physically, but doesn't fit the WCO. MMoore is a 1/2 season wonder times 2 at this point (productive half season for Carolina and a productive half season for us). Maybe he can be our gap guy before Tanny gets up to speed, but he also doesn't fit well in the WCO and will be learning a completely new offense from what he's run here or in Carolina...
Truth be told, you guys also have questions at QB. Sanchez has plateau'd and not really progressed since his rookie season. There are questions about his leadership ability in addition to his physical ability as a QB. He certainly didn't come thru for you guys last year. Tebow is an enigma. Will his presence hurt or help your squad. If Sanchez has a game or two that are not very good, it's likely he'll rescind back into his shell when you guys start chanting "TEBOW!" Tebow is a winner and has all the intangibles you could want in a football player, but is he really a QB ?? Can you depend on him to execute Sparano's offense if Sanchez is hurt or just folds again ?? The thing is, Foxy and crew dumbed down the offense and tailor it to Tebow's game....Can Sparano do the same ?? Will Rexy interfere and force changes ?? Remember, he's a bit on the hot seat as well...
Offensive and Defensive scheme changes: This is major negative for Miami in this conversation... Coyle will likely run a similar D to what we have been running under Nolan, but I don't think he's the same level DC as Nolan at this point. Cincy was a pretty stout D and we carry over a good portion of the group we had, but can they adjust quick enough to be successful and get back to where they were ?? Offensively, again the question goes back to the QB. If that turns out well, then can the WR group we have get the job done. We have a good #3 guy, a mediocre #2 guy and a bunch of unproven other guys... While Philbin's offense isn't predicated on having great WRs, it does require good ones...do we have that group and can they pick up the O quick enough?? Makes even me laugh when I hear talk that we are so much better than last year because Sparano is gone...maybe we are better off, but talent-wise, I'm not convinced we're a lot better than last year...and ultimately, that's what wins games...
You guys, on the other hand are settled in your D, but coming off a down year. You guys, like us last year, despite ranking fairly high in the defensive standings, weren't quite as good as your rankings indicated. Have you settled your pass rushing issues, the one thing that Rexy's D is centered around ?? I don't see major improvement in this offseason... Offensively, it appears you have blamed Sanchez' lack of success on your OC and took up with Sparano. Short term, it's a good move for you. He's good at moving the focus of the O away from your deficiencies, but you guys don't have the OL that you had a couple of years ago to run his ground and pound... As to the RBs, I'd also give us a very, very slight edge overall. I'd say that Bush is better than Greene, but not by much and because of the other things he brings to the table than his pure running ability. They are two very different backs and it's tough to compare them.
All the other non-sense about your team's melt down last season and what not is just that...nonsense. It can easily be fixed and for all of Tony's bad points, one of his good points is that his players love him and that should help that get straightened out. However, if it doesn't and you guys start to lose, it could be a long year...Especially with the TEBOW chants start...
All in all, you guys should have a better season and better team than us. We simply don't know how Philbin will bring this team together. Comparing it to last years' team is not a good gauge to go by. However, your team is closer to being what it was last year than ours is to being worse than it was last season.