How many wins would Rosen need to prove he’s elite?

[Vaark]

Auburn was top 20 until they played Tua. So there goes your top 30 defense argument right out the window like Rosen's potential.

oopoopoopoopoop

 

[royalshank]

Elite? Kid has a lot of developed to do.

 

[Phinatic8u]

So you basically take everything out of the equation: TDs, yards, wins. It all will be crap. Yet you subscribe in a cult-like fashion to a QB who throws against secondaries of which most of the players will never sniff NFL.

No I subscribe to the the cult like fashion of being done with decent qb play on Sundays. It's a pointless endeavor to try to find hope in a decent qb, we lived it for almost a decade and you'd think everyone would be tired of dealing with it, but alas..

 

[phins_4_ever]

No it doesn't. Let's see how he does when facing a time proven good team.. and all this slavish Menudo-level idolation for Tua is kind of embarrassing.. just sayin'

That is an extremely unhealthy man-crush some people have with Tua.

 

[The Goat]

LOL.

Rosen isn't elite. He won't be elite.

I wish he wouldn't have this cult following after a meh preseason, but here we are...

Serious question: Why do you wish that?

If you’re so damned sure he’s never going to be a franchise QB, doesn’t this just give you more to LOL about?

 

[Phinatic8u]

oopoopoopoopoop

Yeah just like the "top 30 defenses" argument that get spouted around by people who adored Ryan Tannehill.

 

[Phinatic8u]

Serious question: Why do you wish that?

If you’re so damned sure he’s never going to be a franchise QB, doesn’t this just give you more to LOL about?

I'm not LOLing aboiut anything, I'm purely smiling cause I know Miami finally gets it. You need an elite qb to win. Getting one is extremely difficult, but you need one.

 

[Avigatorx]

I'm a huge fan of Tua, but if Josh Rosen can make me forget about Tua, Ill be ****ing ecstatic.

 

[Phinatic8u]

I'm a huge fan of Tua, but if Josh Rosen can make me forget about Tua, Ill be ****ing ecstatic.

People think nobody wants this. Everyone here wants this, but some understand the chances of it happening are rare and more than likely will not happen.

 

[phin1984!]

I don't have high hopes for Rosen. At this point, I am die hard Tank4Tua. I understand why some fans would be excited by Rosen, certainly given the context of being a fan of this team the last 20 years.

Im extra excited as we have Tua as a fall back

 

[phin1984!]

I'm a huge fan of Tua, but if Josh Rosen can make me forget about Tua, Ill be ****ing ecstatic.

Something to get exited about whatever happens

 

[rickd13]

That is an extremely unhealthy man-crush some people have with Tua.

Not as unhealthy as your man crush on Rosen. :laugh

 

[Feverdream]

LOL.

Rosen isn't elite. He won't be elite.

I wish he wouldn't have this cult following after a meh preseason, but here we are...

As opposed to the Tua cult?

Heh!

 

[phins_4_ever]

I'm a huge fan of Tua, but if Josh Rosen can make me forget about Tua, Ill be ****ing ecstatic.

That is a good attitude to have. I don't care about a QB in the draft until we know what we have or don't have in Rosen.

But no matter which side you are on Rosen is the starting QB right now. As a Dolphins fan you should be rooting for him to succeed because if he does we have enormous firepower to upgrade the rest of the team. It would accelerate our development.

 

[phin1984!]

He played against 2nd stringers.

Fitzpatrick played against 2nd stringers for a drive against Jacksonville and wen 8-8 and a touchdown, better than Rosen did any time.

Watch the TB game his receivers let him down not that it means much but against NE it was the same story