I've Been Debating Whether Or Not It Would Be Smart.........

[NBP81]

On the other hand you land an elite guy, IE Rogers, Brady, Rothlisberger etc etc you compete for championships year in and year out.

None of those guys were aquired after a trade up...

 

[gofins60]

So don't even give them a chance....got it, makes lots of sense.

Miami's offense and defense under Philbin was a complete failure. Logic dictates to make a change, but Ross hires Gase who wants to run a similar offense and defense. No one would hire Tannenbaum as a GM, but Ross gave him a job. Then, when Tannenbaum should've been fired, Ross promoted him. Every personnel decision that Ross has made has been the wrong one. I say clean house completely and start over from scratch... the odds are that he might find someone better than Philbin/Gase/Tannenbaum/Grier next time because he couldn't get any worse!

 

[Dajesus]

None of those guys were aquired after a trade up...

Nor did I imply they were, so I’m not sure what your point is. I referenced Phi, LA, and the Giants trading up for thier franchise qb.

 

[Travis34]

you get my drift though. no MUT's ratings or even maddens ratings aren't something to go by. what I was saying is, you shouldn't target a slightly better player at a position that is already good, if you don't replace a position you feel has a B- player and add a B+ player, when you are starting a D+ player. A team full of B- players, is better than 2 B+ ,7 B-, and 2 D+. those D players are going to do more damage to your starting unit than the positives of the ones you slightly upgraded. I don't care if Tannehill is rated 50 or 99 in madden, what we see on the field is what matters, I was just using MUT as my thought behind team building. I just think that Tannehill is a B level player where as a start like Anthony at OLB, or if we had to start a current tight end on our rost would be a D, why no focus on bringing that up to at least a B and ignore the QB that's sliding.

Oh no, I totally get what you are saying. Just giving ya a hard time about the mut part my friend