NYinBostonFin
Playoffs Please!!
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2005
- Messages
- 4,604
- Reaction score
- 47
- Age
- 48
NJFINSFAN1 said:
Honestly I was just playing with you. This is the first thread on AJ that I havent argued with you in. I didn't want to break the streak.
Judging Feeley and our offensive for last years performance is absurd…at this point
- Thread starter svnrdr
- Start date
Honestly I was just playing with you. This is the first thread on AJ that I havent argued with you in. I didn't want to break the streak.
guido13
Practice Squad
I think you have to hope for th best. I think people were a little too hard on Jay and you definately cannot judge AJ. They were in horrible offensive sytems with no help and no where to go. Jay was similiar to Brad Johnson (not that I'm a huge fan of him) but he did take the Bucs to the Super Bowl. He had the right SYSTEM in place that played to his strengths and the teams strengths. Jay never had that. He was smart tough, slightly mobile and fairly accurate but has no strength. How many times did we see him throwing the out pattern to the far sideline only to get picked as the cameraman was well ahead of the ball.
AJ is in a similiar situation. He has a great gun, and can squeeze the ball in there. The question is his intelligence and judgement. He has to do a better play fake and must look off the recievers. It's those little things that can make the difference between backup and starter. He could all the raw physical talent but if he doesn't learn to do those little things and study the game better he will always be a backup.
AJ is in a similiar situation. He has a great gun, and can squeeze the ball in there. The question is his intelligence and judgement. He has to do a better play fake and must look off the recievers. It's those little things that can make the difference between backup and starter. He could all the raw physical talent but if he doesn't learn to do those little things and study the game better he will always be a backup.
painnotpleasure
Hall Of Famer
Whomever performs better should win the starting job... If not, I think we're making a really big mistake. I hope Saban feels the same way because I truly believe that's most practical intelligent way to go about it. It's up to Saban and the coaching staff to decide who is the better man for the job (not for us to decide... we just have our opinions). The best man for the job, should win the job. I don't see why anyone else would want anything differently? :confused:svnrdr said:
(Not targeting you personally svnrdr or anything like that.)
chambers#1wr
Dolphin Wide Out
Guss is old hes not gunna start get over it people aj might not be the future but hes better than gus. Roth is gonna dominate. He ate Big 10 quarterbacks alive and will continue to do so. tom brady is gunna die.
Ohio Fanatic
FinHeaven VIP
NJFINSFAN1 said:
Do you honestly believe Gus Frerotte would have done any better in last years offense? I seriously doubt it. So your bias against Feeley (IMO) is unfounded and is getting pretty old.
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2001
- Messages
- 9,591
- Reaction score
- 1
You guys should get Jeff blake. If he can get the ball to Boldin, he can get it to Chambers :couch:
painnotpleasure said:
No offense taken...
You are ABSOLUTELY right in saying it is Saban's decision, and thank GOD it is...LOL
It is just my opinion if there is room for improvement, then you go with the 78 and groom him. Again this is just conjecture, but I go with the young guy...Although Gus has proven effective, I think he is on the downside of his carreer.
chambers#1wr
Dolphin Wide Out
Ohio Fanatic said:
And gus isnt getting old we dont need an outstanding qb but frerotte isn gunna cut it
themole
FinHeaven VIP
NJFINSFAN1 said:
The point is...from us so called Feely apologist, NO ONE knows what AJ is capable of until he gets his chance behind a line that will give him protection. Running an offense that he is accustom to with hot reads, a place to safely dump the ball to if no one is open.
His accuracy is far superior to that of Jay. He has a much stronger arm to stretch the field than Jay had, the potential IS there. The EXCUSES are legitimate.
If AJ can't cut the mustard after playing behind an improved O-Line and legitimate offensive NFL scheme then I'll be right there with you in his condemnation.
There have been many stories written about how frustrated Norv was with Wanny due to play selection and game planning, or lack there of. Norv basicly threw in the towel as OC and got the hell out of Miami ASAP.
Nick Saban obviously sees something in AJ or he would have acted on replacing him with the opportunity he had during the draft. He is an excellent evaluator of talent, do you not agree?
Again, the point is, neither you nor I, or the rest of the fans, pro or con AJ Feely are making the call on who's QBing the Dolphins next year. The best man will most assuredly be under center in the fall.
Here's hoping that whoever is running the offense next year is up to the task, and has the fans full support.
I'm thinking that AJ can get the job done enough to make the offense productive.
NJFINSFAN1
FinHeaven Elite
NYinBostonFin said:
:roflmao:
arsenal
Beastin'
cant wait for the season already...............
NJFINSFAN1
FinHeaven Elite
svnrdr said:
I really feel if AJ can't beat out Gus, he does not deserve it. If it's really that close, it goes to Saban, but would you feel good about AJ if it was that close?
He was that close to Jay last year.
I would like to see him take the reins and win it outright!