Playing it safe in the draft can get any GM to find starters...we need impact players and we need skill position players. The bar has to be raised. Comparing him to his predecessors is not the comparison we need. How does he compare with the best GMs in the league? Atlanta (who has drafted amazingly well since Thomas Demitroff was hired as GM in 2008), Green Bay and San Francisco? Teams that not only get starters but impact players. This is where Ireland has fallen short. He needs to break out of his comfort zone of drafting O-line and D-line early and get those skill positions that change a game...that big play WR, the shutdown corner, the unblockable DE, the linebacker that goes sideline to sideline (and can cover a TE). That's what we need.
Agreed. Anyone can draft a bunch of lunch-pail starters when the team already sucks to begin with, having no starters. I mean, I see a lot of starters every week who suck balls. Saw many guys on the NY Jets tonight that I wouldn't want to see starting on my team, but they're starting in the NFL, and some of them for years. The two tackles in Arizona are starting and they suck sht, getting eaten alive every week looking like fat human turnstiles. They're starting, and so ??!! so what !
The difference is impact players. Impact players win games in the playoffs. And Ireland sucks at this & stinks in the skill position department (both offense and defense)
Anyone see JJ Watt tonight ?? Or in his 5 games this year as I did ?? In just his 2nd year, now THAT is an impact player who impacts the game in many ways. We have nothing like that on this team. Sherman's boy Tannehill may be one for us, but he's not there yet and may not be for a couple more years.
For those that may bring up Reggie Bush. He isn't a top level impact guy. Impact guys are reliable, durable, and you can't rely on Bush because if a player as much as breathes on him he's favoring an arm, shoulder or leg in games, and isn't the same player in games. How many times have we seen Bush receive a good lick from a defender just to watch him favoring something and is gimpy the rest of the way. He turns it down two notches. He becomes just another guy at that point, fragile, as we saw the past 2 weeks, and at various points last season when he was needed but impotent. The problem with him is its happened way too often during his career. He's not going to all-of-a-sudden become an ironman. He's only the real and healthy Reggie Bush 35% of the time.
Cam Wake is a nice pass rusher, but that's all he does is rush, and we have no help for him. It's not like Cam Wake is a Lawrence Taylor who disrupted plays all over the field causing fumbles and INT's like a madman,, now Taylor was an impact defender. Or a Ray Lewis or Derrick Thomas. Wake could be slightly more of an impact but the problem is Miami has no impact on the other side to help open him up.
We need a lot more impact. Against Top playoff defenses like Baltimore and the Steelers in the playoffs, you better have those impact guys or else you'll get shut down and playing golf rather quickly... because those defenses have serious impact players ... kind of like how Houston shut Miami down with just 3 points of offense (the TD came off a punt return) .. How Baltimore totally embarrassed Miami in the 2008 playoffs with their impact players on defense making Miami's non-impact offense look like total crap
You must have those impact guys when it counts. You're not going to encounter Oakland caliber defenses very often in the higher-octane playoffs when everything is turned up a notch,, and you're not going to encounter poor QB's in the playoffs very often - so you need those impact guys on defense as well to counter that disadvantage. Hell, we had Marino for what, 17 years ?? What an impact he was, but it wasn't close to being enough to win a title . You need a few of them, like the 49ers had when they absolutely destroyed Miami in Marino's only super bowl appearance.. Because when one or two of them are having an off-day, you've got 3 or 4 other impact guys making a huge difference in games.
I mean Houston with JJ Watt, Arian Foster, Andre Johnson, Cushing, etc.. all impact guys. I take all those guys over our guys at the same positions every day of the week and twice on sundays. The dolphins need a few impact players , and a real leader on defense (Dansby is no leader, neither is Wake)