Why is it ridiculous? I dont know how anyone could watch Tannehill and think he's even close to those 2 QBs. Like the poster said, the improvisation is what separates them. Despite his speed Tanny almost never extends plays
When given the time those QBs get, Tanerhill has been money. I am not saying he is as good, let alone better, but if Miami had actually provided him an O-line that had him pissing blood...a debate might have been made that few would think Crazy.