It's hard to say C-Pep because he's coming off a horrible season and then tearing the 3 ligaments in the knee. I'd say Brady, he still lead the league in yards last year, plus he's got Chad Jackson now.
Justasportsfan said:Haha! No one even knows if Culp will ever be the same qb he once was and yet you're picking him over a HOF qb in his prime?
Culpepper situation
Having mentioned Culpepper, it’s worth noting that the Dolphins are increasingly optimistic about his chances to open the season as the starting quarterback. Culpepper recently received a strong evaluation from Dr. James Andrews, the renowned orthopedic surgeon who repaired the three torn ligaments in Culpepper’s right knee, coach Nick Saban said.
The Dolphins were close to turning down the trade for Harrington altogether recently because of Culpepper’s progress. Miami was almost willing to wait until Harrington was cut in June before making a move for him. The problem is that Harrington would have missed all of the Dolphins offseason program if they had waited, putting him way behind.
One final note on the Dolphins quarterbacks: The team has completely reworked its depth chart over the past eight months. After opening last season with A.J. Feeley, Gus Frerotte and Sage Rosenfels, the team has traded for Culpepper, Harrington and third stringer Cleo Lemon.
The funny part is that in trading for Feeley and Rosenfels, former Dolphins general manager Rick Spielman and coach Dave Wannstedt gave up second- and seventh-round picks for two guys who had seven games of experience between them. To get the current three, the Dolphins gave up a second and two sixths. They got three quarterbacks with a combined three Pro Bowl appearances and 139 games of experience.
Justasportsfan said:Haha! No one even knows if Culp will ever be the same qb he once was and yet you're picking him over a HOF qb in his prime?
Justasportsfan said:qb's that win a sb in their 2nd year and their first start don't grow on trees. Not even Dan the Man could achieve that. How many sb MVP's does Culp have?
I hate Brady as much as anyone here but I'm not gonna be a homer about it.
Ayuh said:Comparing apples to oranges. And when will people learn that stats are for fantasy football, talking head hype, and fan folly.
Bury this thread until the seasons end, and then debate "which QB will dominate the AFCE".
Justasportsfan said:Only a finfan would think he's a HOF at this point. :wink:
BleedinGreenNC said:Even when Culpepper is healthy, he is nowhere near Brady, Christ, you would have thought that this is the second coming of Marino in here. This guy is not your next Marino guys, your going to have a great year, but it will be because of Ronnie and your defense.
PhinSoldia said:everytime i see you post i ask one fundamental question.....WHY ARE YOU HERE!!!!!
Dirtywater said:Hey Ayuh....
Pretty weak using a graphic I made for your sig without my permission and then going one classless step further by taking my watermark off it. :fire: