Thats how I always felt about Harrington. We all know he sucks. We knew that when we got him from Detroit. We didnt give up a 2nd round pick, pay him 8 million, and put hopes in him leading us anywhere. The guy went 5-6 vs a tough slate of teams. I dont think he can seriously be brought up in this discussion. But thats just MO. The only reason he had to play was because he was brought in in favor of the guy who was truly the worst phins QB ever.
Feely is 2 and Lucas is 3. Both played almost as poorly as Culpepper in their starts but, Lucas was meant to be a backup as well. Lucas killed our season that year when we had a good team. Feely was a waste of a 2nd round pick. Culpepper did both of those things and played as poorly. Certainly Feely and Lucas are much worse players from a career standpoint yes, but when it comes to worst PHINS QB ever Culpepper gets the nod for reasons above.