I apologize for not overrating peyton manning like everyone else, you probably think peyton is better than Brady
ESPN: Jets looking to trade up for Sanchez
- Thread starter UT the Jet
- Start date
I apologize for not overrating peyton manning like everyone else, you probably think peyton is better than Brady
ArmyFin7
U cry about the $$$, we do the dirtywork
Actually, I do think Peyton is better than Brady. I apolagize for not swinging from brady's sac like most fans seem to.
w/ that opinion please don't talk about other posters looking ridiculous b/c Manning is not even close to Brady.
Finch83
Starter
Ummm I would say Peyton is at LEAST the 2nd best QB in the NFL...
ArmyFin7
U cry about the $$$, we do the dirtywork
I guess maybe Im just more of a traditionalist....when brady gous out onto the field and calls his own plays because of what the defense shows him instead of doing what some guy in a booth says, maybe then I will rank them together.
he's calling the wrong plays in January.
SpaceMountain16
Disgruntled
Manning isn't even half as good as Brady.
Lilseb93
This Is My House
BS!
I want to see how Brady does on another team. He's in the perfect system with all of the weapons he wants. Even when they had no talent, the Pats won the SB a while ago from GREAT coaching. I may get flamed for this, but I think Brady is a slightly above average QB in a great system. Manning is great, but he has nothing to carry him to championships. Neither of them can be compared to Marino, Elway, Namoth, Montana, ect. This is my opinion.
Manning loses the big games against SD all the time. He HATES SD. He won the SB, so apparently he wins the big games.
Lilseb93
This Is My House
The best QB's are Brees, then Manning, then Big Ben, then Brady, then Rivers, then Ryan, then Cutler, ect.
WHAT??? Manning has played w/ supreme offensive talent his entire career. Brady played w/ talent like that ONCE and broke Manning's TD record(playing outdoors) and led his team back to the Super Bowl.
NE was a franchise in steep decline until Brady became their starter. From 1996-2000 they got worse each year goijng from 11 to 10 to 9 to 8 to 5 wins and then started out 0-2 in 2001 before Brady became the starter. Brady is THE reason NE is now a premiere franchise. Belichick has been a HC for 14 years, he coached w/o Brady as his QB for 7 years and made just ONE postseason going 1-1 in the '94 postseason. He has coached w/ Brady as his QB for 7 years and has made the postseason 6 times including 4 SBs winning 3 of them. Brady is so underrated it's ridiculous meanwhile Manning chokes year after year in January and he is ridiculously overrated.
No offense but that is an awful list. Brees is overrated, manning is overrated, ryan hasn't proven himself yet and Cutler is overrated.
ArmyFin7
U cry about the $$$, we do the dirtywork
When a guy like Cassell can step in and win 11 games....it doesnt help Brady look so god-like.
SpaceMountain16
Disgruntled
If you've ever watched Tom Brady in a big game, a playoff game, and Peyton Manning in a big game a playoff game. There really is no comparison. Brady carried the Patriots to 3 super bowls before they ever had any real significant weapons on offense, Peyton Manning couldn't even win a playoff game for a number of years surrounded by pro-bowl talent. Brady is the guy who leads his team down field late in big games for the win. Manning is the guy who drops back and turns into a statue, taking ridiculous sacks and looking like a rookie. Brady is MUCH better than Peyton Manning.
The Pats lost 6 more games w/o Brady last year. That is a HUGE difference. In a year where the div was average w/ no bad teams but no great teams and a pretty soft non-div sched.