FinHeaven Fantasy NFL Keeper Draft

[HBCF4Ever]

I would be against radomizing the order....the teams at the top mostly have a clear disadvantage as to the players available to keep. I picked the Rams to have a high pick, and have marginal keepers because of it (but slightly better than the Lions offered)

Maybe not a random order, but how about a snake draft? The teams at the top have a huge advantage right now over the bottom half teams. Of course, the argument can be that the teams at the top of the draft have lesser players and don't have the talent to pick from that the teams at the bottom have. I would counter that you can take a team such as Cleveland and take an All-Pro LT, Pro Bowl receiver, and a potential franchise QB in Brady Quinn. Just my two cents.

 

[burger13]

Maybe not a random order, but how about a snake draft? The teams at the top have a huge advantage right now over the bottom half teams. Of course, the argument can be that the teams at the top of the draft have lesser players and don't have the talent to pick from that the teams at the bottom have. I would counter that you can take a team such as Cleveland and take an All-Pro LT, Pro Bowl receiver, and a potential franchise QB in Brady Quinn. Just my two cents.

I would think we should snake....but maybe after 2 rounds of going 1 to 32. This would be a decent way to balance things out.

 

[SwimminInIndy]

The starter or CEO of this has already said that it is going to snake. I think if (and I think we should) we snake we should just do it all the way through. That is how good fantasy leagues are run, so we should do the same.

 

[Dolfan3773]

Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams- burger13 - Stephen Jackson, Chris Long, O.Atogwe
3. Kansas City Chiefs-
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish-Joe Thomas, Braylon Edwards, Shaun Rodgers
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-Ricky4Life: Patrick Willis, Frank Gore, Vernon Davis.
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers- CedarPhin- Phillip Rivers, Cromartie, Marcus McNeil
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears- Fish-Head - Jay Cutler, Lance Briggs, Matt Forte
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys- Finsguy939- Romo, Ware, Newman
21. Philladelphia Eagles-Brian Westbrook, Desean Jackson, Trent Cole
22. Minnesota Vikings-FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. peterson, J. Allen, B. mckinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons- rothshunger-matt ryan,roddy white,micheal turner
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-KDog13 - Steve Smith, DeAngelo Williams, Jon Beason
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals- Outlawd2u - Larry Fitzgerald, Karlos Dansby, Dominique Rogers-Cromartie
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-Dolfan3773: Troy Polamalu, James Harrison, Ben Roethlisberger

 

[KDog13]

Carolina Panthers

-Jon Beason- An absolute beast and which i believe he can be an amazing mlb for years to come. Has the speed and awareness to stop any runningback in his tracts and also is a good coverage mlb. Basically and all around guy. His name should be Jon Beaston.

-Steve Smith- Has been a dominate force at Wr. Yeah he is a small guy but his speed, jumping ability, and just ability to get wide open is awesume. The man is no Todd Pinkston he will catch the ball even if he knows he is going to get laid out. Top 5 best receivers in the game no doubt.

-DeAngelo Williams- First off all let me say he was snubbed of getting into the pro bowl and absolute stud. He is very quick and dynamic just look at last year 1515 yards, 18 tds and a 5.5 avg wow now thats sick. A great player to build your franchise around

Sucks its hard leaving Peppers out he is such a beast when healthy but these guys are the franchise players in my mind especially when he doesn't even want to be with this franchise

.Other notables

-Richard Marshall they dropped ken lucas who is an excellent cornerback to start this guy i guess they think he is a key franchise player

-Chris Gamble awesume player 20 picks in 5 years but 13 in his first is crazy

lol did i say too much

 

[JimToss]

If I missed anyone so far just yell.

Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams- burger13 - Stephen Jackson, Chris Long, O.Atogwe
3. Kansas City Chiefs-
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish-Joe Thomas, Braylon Edwards, Shaun Rodgers
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-Jamarcus Russel, Darren McFadden, Nnambi Asomugha
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-Ricky4Life: Patrick Willis, Frank Gore, Vernon Davis.
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers- CedarPhin- Phillip Rivers, Cromartie, Marcus McNeil
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears- Fish-Head - Jay Cutler, Lance Briggs, Matt Forte
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys- Finsguy939- Romo, Ware, Newman
21. Philladelphia Eagles-Brian Westbrook, Desean Jackson, Trent Cole
22. Minnesota Vikings-FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. peterson, J. Allen, B. mckinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons- rothshunger-matt ryan,roddy white,micheal turner
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-KDog13 - Steve Smith, DeAngelo Williams, Jon Beason
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals- Outlawd2u - Larry Fitzgerald, Karlos Dansby, Dominique Rogers-Cromartie
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-Dolfan3773: Troy Polamalu, James Harrison, Ben Roethlisberger

 

[emeraldfin]

1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams- burger13 - Stephen Jackson, Chris Long, O.Atogwe
3. Kansas City Chiefs- Emeraldfin: Matt Cassell, Branden Albert, Dwayne Bowe
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish-Joe Thomas, Braylon Edwards, Shaun Rodgers
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-Jamarcus Russel, Darren McFadden, Nnambi Asomugha
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-Ricky4Life: Patrick Willis, Frank Gore, Vernon Davis.
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers- CedarPhin- Phillip Rivers, Cromartie, Marcus McNeil
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears- Fish-Head - Jay Cutler, Lance Briggs, Matt Forte
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys- Finsguy939- Romo, Ware, Newman
21. Philladelphia Eagles-Brian Westbrook, Desean Jackson, Trent Cole
22. Minnesota Vikings-FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. peterson, J. Allen, B. mckinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons- rothshunger-matt ryan,roddy white,micheal turner
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-KDog13 - Steve Smith, DeAngelo Williams, Jon Beason
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals- Outlawd2u - Larry Fitzgerald, Karlos Dansby, Dominique Rogers-Cromartie
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-Dolfan3773: Troy Polamalu, James Harrison, Ben Roethlisberger

 

[emeraldfin]

If I missed anyone so far just yell.

Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams- burger13 - Stephen Jackson, Chris Long, O.Atogwe
3. Kansas City Chiefs-
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish-Joe Thomas, Braylon Edwards, Shaun Rodgers
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-Jamarcus Russel, Darren McFadden, Nnambi Asomugha
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-Ricky4Life: Patrick Willis, Frank Gore, Vernon Davis.
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints-
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers- CedarPhin- Phillip Rivers, Cromartie, Marcus McNeil
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears- Fish-Head - Jay Cutler, Lance Briggs, Matt Forte
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys- Finsguy939- Romo, Ware, Newman
21. Philladelphia Eagles-Brian Westbrook, Desean Jackson, Trent Cole
22. Minnesota Vikings-FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. peterson, J. Allen, B. mckinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons- rothshunger-matt ryan,roddy white,micheal turner
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-KDog13 - Steve Smith, DeAngelo Williams, Jon Beason
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals- Outlawd2u - Larry Fitzgerald, Karlos Dansby, Dominique Rogers-Cromartie
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-Dolfan3773: Troy Polamalu, James Harrison, Ben Roethlisberger

Think the Saints have been taken Jim. Think Milldog took Drew Brees, Marques Colston, Pierre Thomas

 

[JimToss]

Thanks Emerald, its getting harder and harder to keep track. Welcome to the group.
Sorry about that Milldog.
Updated. Again if missed just yell.

1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams- burger13 - Stephen Jackson, Chris Long, O.Atogwe
3. Kansas City Chiefs- Emeraldfin: Matt Cassell, Branden Albert, Dwayne Bowe
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish-Joe Thomas, Braylon Edwards, Shaun Rodgers
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-Jamarcus Russel, Darren McFadden, Nnambi Asomugha
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers-
10. San Francisco 49ERS-Ricky4Life: Patrick Willis, Frank Gore, Vernon Davis.
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints- Miidog-Drew Brees, Marques Colston, Pierre Thomas
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers- CedarPhin- Phillip Rivers, Cromartie, Marcus McNeil
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears- Fish-Head - Jay Cutler, Lance Briggs, Matt Forte
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys- Finsguy939- Romo, Ware, Newman
21. Philladelphia Eagles-Brian Westbrook, Desean Jackson, Trent Cole
22. Minnesota Vikings-FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. peterson, J. Allen, B. mckinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons- rothshunger-matt ryan,roddy white,micheal turner
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-KDog13 - Steve Smith, DeAngelo Williams, Jon Beason
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals- Outlawd2u - Larry Fitzgerald, Karlos Dansby, Dominique Rogers-Cromartie
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-Dolfan3773: Troy Polamalu, James Harrison, Ben Roethlisberger

 

[HBCF4Ever]

Colts and Giants are still around. Nobody wants to keep the Manning brothers??

 

[Aqua Shadow]

Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams- burger13 - Stephen Jackson, Chris Long, O.Atogwe
3. Kansas City Chiefs- Emeraldfin: Matt Cassell, Branden Albert, Dwayne Bowe
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish-Joe Thomas, Braylon Edwards, Shaun Rodgers
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-Jamarcus Russel, Darren McFadden, Nnambi Asomugha
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers- 1 dol fan: Arron Rodgers, Greg Jennings, Aaron Kampman.
10. San Francisco 49ERS-Ricky4Life: Patrick Willis, Frank Gore, Vernon Davis.
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints- Milldog-Drew Brees, Marques Colston, Pierre Thomas
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers- CedarPhin- Phillip Rivers, Cromartie, Marcus McNeil
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears- Fish-Head - Jay Cutler, Lance Briggs, Matt Forte
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys- Finsguy939- Romo, Ware, Newman
21. Philladelphia Eagles-Brian Westbrook, Desean Jackson, Trent Cole
22. Minnesota Vikings-FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. peterson, J. Allen, B. mckinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons- rothshunger-matt ryan,roddy white,micheal turner
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts-
28. Carolina Panthers-KDog13 - Steve Smith, DeAngelo Williams, Jon Beason
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals- Outlawd2u - Larry Fitzgerald, Karlos Dansby, Dominique Rogers-Cromartie
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-Dolfan3773: Troy Polamalu, James Harrison, Ben Roethlisbergeren Roethlisberger

 

[MDFinFan06]

Here is the Order/Participants/Keepers.
1. Detroit Lions-
2. St. Louis Rams- burger13 - Stephen Jackson, Chris Long, O.Atogwe
3. Kansas City Chiefs- Emeraldfin: Matt Cassell, Branden Albert, Dwayne Bowe
4. Seattle Seahawks-
5. Cleveland Browns- Clownfish-Joe Thomas, Braylon Edwards, Shaun Rodgers
6. Cincinatti Bengals-
7. Oakland Raiders-Jamarcus Russel, Darren McFadden, Nnambi Asomugha
8. Jacksonville Jaguars-
9. Green Bay Packers- 1 dol fan: Arron Rodgers, Greg Jennings, Aaron Kampman.
10. San Francisco 49ERS-Ricky4Life: Patrick Willis, Frank Gore, Vernon Davis.
11. Buffalo Bills-
12. Denver Broncos-
13. Washington Redskins- FINatic 13-Albert Haynesworth, Chris Cooley, Clinton Portis
14. New Orleans Saints- Milldog-Drew Brees, Marques Colston, Pierre Thomas
15. Houston Texans- JimToss- Matt Shaub, Andre Johnson, Mario Williams
16. San Diego Chargers- CedarPhin- Phillip Rivers, Cromartie, Marcus McNeil
17. New York Jets-
18. Chicago Bears- Fish-Head - Jay Cutler, Lance Briggs, Matt Forte
19. Tampa Bay Buccaneers-
20. Dallas Cowboys- Finsguy939- Romo, Ware, Newman
21. Philladelphia Eagles-Brian Westbrook, Desean Jackson, Trent Cole
22. Minnesota Vikings-FinsFan_in_Iraq: A. peterson, J. Allen, B. mckinnie
23. New England Pats-HBCF4Ever-Tom Brady, Vince Wilfork, Jerod Mayo
24. Atlanta Falcons- rothshunger-matt ryan,roddy white,micheal turner
25. Miami Dolphins- Tylerdolphin- Jake Long, Ronnie Brown, Vernon Carey
26. Baltimore Ravens-SwimminInIndy-Ed Reed, Joe Flacco, Haloti Ngata
27. Indianapolis Colts- Mdfinfan06- Payton Manning, Dwight Freeney, Bob Sanders
28. Carolina Panthers-KDong13 - Steve Smith, DeAngelo Williams, Jon Beason
29. New York Giants-
30. Tennessee Titans-
31. Arizona Cardinals- Outlawd2u - Larry Fitzgerald, Karlos Dansby, Dominique Rogers-Cromartie
32. Pittsburgh Steelers-Dolfan3773: Troy Polamalu, James Harrison, Ben Roethlisbergeren Roethlisberger

 

[Bahama Fin Fan]

Does anyone want the first pick? Will you make up a list of all the free agents to make it easier to pick?

 

[JimToss]

Does anyone want the first pick? Will you make up a list of all the free agents to make it easier to pick?

Absolutely not. That would include everyone in the NFL minus 96 players.

You pick with your own wits. There will be a large time limit (~24hrs) to account for different timezones/people actually having lives, so there will be time to do your research.

 

[Bahama Fin Fan]

okay, I'll take Detroit. Let me keep Calvin Johnson-the best player on the team, Ernie Sims-strong young defender, and Jeff Backus-always keep good linemen