OK sell me on Drew Stanton. Aside from his pathetic collection on zero stats. Is he better now compared his MSU days? Has he developed at all?
Well he's actually an NFL quarterback now, so that's a positive step in the right direction, lol.
There's no being "sold" on Drew Stanton or any of these guys, even Carson Palmer who is old with an injury history, questionable motivation and even more questionable recent play.
If you want to know how Drew Stanton plays the game I can tell you what I've seen. I see a guy with kind of a slow hitchy release who ends up a shade late on a lot of his throws as a result. I see a guy with quick feet and the ability to really hurt teams on the run, but a little bit questionable accuracy on the move. The feet are a big advantage. You know how we always seem to get victimized by the QB draw from shotgun on the goal line? He can run that play and run it well. I see a guy with enough arm strength to make things happen on the field, but whose lack of natural arm probably results in high throws and the long delivery, and may figure into his lack of touch. He does lack touch on his short passes and isn't a very good screen thrower, either on the perimeter (where the ball can be placed badly) or to the tailback. On the other hand, his feet give him the promise of being a terrific screen executor to the tailback because he can REALLY draw defenders that extra step toward him and then get the ball to a guy knifing against the grain. If he could improve his touch on screen passes that would be a boon to his game. He's accurate but doesn't have the uncanny accuracy that makes the best who they are. It's tough to say how accurate he is on deep passes based on the number of throws I've seen, but my instincts say not very. Pro Football Focus has him completing 5 of 19 over the last three years at 20+ yard depth. That sounds about right. I see a guy that benefited from Calvin Johnson's presence, which is both good and bad. It's good in that he knew when to find Calvin and trusted him. With 8 seconds remaining in the game against the Buccaneers, with one chance to make a throw and win the game otherwise kick a field goal and go into overtime, he didn't give a rat's arse that Calvin's fade pattern was off the far hash. He threw it and placed the ball well, gave Calvin Johnson the opportunity to do what he does. Just so happens Calvin didn't come down with it, but compare that to when Chad Henne had a choice between a fade to Brandon Marshall or a fade to Brian Hartline in a critical moment in a game, and he chose Hartline because he was closer. Stanton wouldn't have done that.
Actually when watching Stanton, I don't know if it was the route concepts commonly thrown or what, but he reminded me a lot of Chad Henne. A little weaker arm. Not as much accuracy intermediate. Probably the same accuracy deep. Similar ball placement criticisms. Same issues with being a little late, Stanton because of his delivery and Henne because of his relaxed brain. Same kind of patterns being thrown. Henne a little better touch. Stanton way more athletic on his feet, which presents more options in the play calling (stretches, draws, screens, etc).
I think the more you look at the guys out there and available, the more you realize that aside from Carson Palmer, whose availability to us is questionable at best, Vince Young is the only guy out there with a lick of real talent remaining to him. And that's sad, because of the problems in Vince's personality that make him the next Jeff George.