When I was a kid, my favorite player was Nat Moore. He was the clutch receiver for so many years. Third down and 7? Nat's on the other end for a 1st-down.
He was my favorite too - may have had the softest hands of any fins receiver. I'll never forget the game in '81, where we were trailing the Jets 21-0 or something. Shula pulls Woodley for Strock and he and Moore go nuts for over 200 receiving yards and 2 TDS - and 3 all-out diving, over the shoulder bombs he caught that day. The game ended in a tie 28-28.
The obvious one is Marino. I loved Jim Jensen, Clayton and Duper, Doug Betters, Bob Baumhower, AJ Duhe and the Blackwood Brothers. In recent years its JT, Zach, Ricky Williams.