bluehaze said:I just don't see how you can call Harrington a lousy starter, say he will never be good with any team ever and then follow that statement up by saying Culpepper is a solid QB. Harrington has done far better as a Dolphin than Culpepper has, the last solid season Culpepper has had will be three years removed going into next season.
Harrington is the cheaper option, Culpepper is going into his ninth season next year and has played on some very good teams. Obviously he's shown what he has and that he is on the decline at this point. Harrington on the other hand has never played for a good team and has alot more unanswered questions with regard to his future.
How can you be more confident someone who has never had a good year will have one, then someone who has been an elite QB will not return to form? You base this on 4 games where culpepper was injured but played well at times and badly at times.
Culpepper is a 3-time pro-bowler. Joey Harrington is a ... He's never accomplished anything, But you want to keep Harrington and groom someone under him? Over a 3-time pro-bowler? If you weren't on a Phins site I think you would be laughed off.
Minnesota let go of Culpepper for a reason, he demanded a trade. From this point on, NOBODY should say Minny let go Daunte for a reason and insinuate it was based on injuries or ability.
Does anyone research anything anymore or do they just spew the same inaccurate facts over and over?
http://www.startribune.com/510/story/168837.html
Daunte Culpepper right now is the franchise quarterback," Childress said Friday in the Vikings' Winter Park locker room. "That's how they signed him. He's the guy. We'll just leave it at that."
"We saw Daunte Culpepper work out first, and I thought I would never see another workout like that as long as I lived," Childress said. "The next workout was Donovan McNabb. And saw another one ... that was mind-boggling. "In my mind, we got the No. 1 player, but Daunte was a very close second. He fits right into all the things that we'll do."