I’m not saying Herbert is Marino or Tua is Joe Montana but the contrast in styles and physical abilities reminds me of that argument. That being said, I’ll still take Tua but I was higher on Herbert than most.
Dolphins blew it with passing on Herbert
- Thread starter dolphinfan41
- Start date
Sure hope so but man I am a bit jealous of what I have seenHe's gonna be good . So is the one we got
Why can't both things be true
Herbert goes downfield constantly from the limited viewing I have done
TrogdorTheBurninator
Club Member
How can you be jealous after seeing Tua progress these last few weeks? Are you watching Dolphins games at all?
He's gonna be good . So is the one we got
Why can't both things be true
Why? Because THIS IS FINHEAVEN!!!
I am happy Tua is looking the way he is and that injuries to skill players & lack of skill players have impact
But Herbert looks commanding out there and does show glimpses of Marinoish ability throwing that ball
Just my opinion
Pachyderm_Wave
Hartselle Tigers (15-0) 5-A State Champ
- Joined
- Jul 28, 2008
- Messages
- 15,323
- Reaction score
- 13,905
These type of threads are just people fishing for attention. The passed over quarterback is always going to be the favorite topic for agitators lurking internet forums.
The hate for Alabama is real and it's been there for 100 years. I wouldn't be here if the presence of it wasn't so strong around here and I didn't enjoy it.
Some just want Tua to fail so badly just because they never liked him or Alabama. They'll attempt to will it into existence every week - or at least the weeks when Herbert doesn't turn the football over numerous times and get shut out.
Tua -1
Marinobert - 0
The hate for Alabama is real and it's been there for 100 years. I wouldn't be here if the presence of it wasn't so strong around here and I didn't enjoy it.
Some just want Tua to fail so badly just because they never liked him or Alabama. They'll attempt to will it into existence every week - or at least the weeks when Herbert doesn't turn the football over numerous times and get shut out.
Tua -1
Marinobert - 0
Last edited:
TrogdorTheBurninator
Club Member
I mean pot calling the kettle black here, but I 100% agree
39wildman
Active Roster
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2008
- Messages
- 7,186
- Reaction score
- 3,635
They may not be closed but Tua is winning and Herbert is losing games
Or he well could end up on the Carson Wentz career trajectory
ToondaGoat
Active Roster
I mean he just had 3 straight game winning drives. Throwing the ball... 2 games vs 2 teams Tua was benched against.
ToondaGoat
Active Roster
Tua has been benched more than Herbert has been shutout. Herbert has 2 games with multiple turnovers. Maybe if Tua was throwing further than 5 yds or not getting benched he might have more turnovers.
Yessir
Dolfan for Life
Tua has as many wins as Herbert does as a starter.... in 6 less starts, including out playing Herbert head to head when the Chargers came to Miami. I’ll take that.
And I’ll take Tua long term too
ToondaGoat
Active Roster
No he doesn't. Herbert has 5 wins. What does tua have 6? Most on the back of his defense and st.