39wildman
Active Roster
Bottom line next yr. Tua must be better. Rookie grown painI mean he just had 3 straight game winning drives. Throwing the ball... 2 games vs 2 teams Tua was benched against.
Bottom line next yr. Tua must be better. Rookie grown painI mean he just had 3 straight game winning drives. Throwing the ball... 2 games vs 2 teams Tua was benched against.
No he doesn't. Herbert has 5 wins. What does tua have 6? Most on the back of his defense and st.
There is no question in my mind that if Herbert was on the Dolphins, putting up those numbers, but losing because he was on a bad team with a bad coach, while Tua was on the Chargers, playing fair to well, and winning while being buoyed by a great coach and a strong defense, that nobody here would say that Tua was better.I agree with the Tua pick at the time and still think he’s going to be a good to great pro.
With that said you can’t say there is no argument that Herbert also deserved to be the pick for us. He’s is playing great football as a rookie and he is hamstringed by arguably one of the worst coaches in the NFL. If Herbert was on this team you could argue he would be better than Tua this far. It’s a fair debate.
The Different between college and pro..Tua is all star in college now avg or sometimes struggling in pros..
Yes I agree but Tua plays the main position in NFL..all eye will be on him more than other. He still rookie..next yr will tell more off story on Tua..Lot of players around Tua struggling in pros too.
Can we just accept both will be top flight NFL qb. Its not a zero sum game. Stop putting down either one just to justify your pre draft expection.I agree with the Tua pick at the time and still think he’s going to be a good to great pro.
With that said you can’t say there is no argument that Herbert also deserved to be the pick for us. He’s is playing great football as a rookie and he is hamstringed by arguably one of the worst coaches in the NFL. If Herbert was on this team you could argue he would be better than Tua this far. It’s a fair debate.
I didn't put either one down if you read what I wrote. I praised both of them.Can we just accept both will be top flight NFL qb. Its not a zero sum game. Stop putting down either one just to justify your pre draft expection.
Not directed at you. It was for others, and they know who they are.I didn't put either one down if you read what I wrote. I praised both of them.
ThisI agree with the Tua pick at the time and still think he’s going to be a good to great pro.
With that said you can’t say there is no argument that Herbert also deserved to be the pick for us. He’s is playing great football as a rookie and he is hamstringed by arguably one of the worst coaches in the NFL. If Herbert was on this team you could argue he would be better than Tua this far. It’s a fair debate.